SMH article - Brad to worse

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/michael-jordan-style-doco-to-reveal-secret-world-of-state-of-origin-20201017-p56630.html

Written by Danny weidler. 


Brad to worse

Parramatta have a growing problem: the division between general manager of football Mark O’Neill and coach Brad Arthur.

In the days since the Eels went out of the finals in straight sets, losing 38-24 in dramatic fashion to Souths last weekend, Arthur has been under real pressure – somewhat unfairly, considering they were a Mitchell Moses penalty miss and aDamien Cook non-sin binning from potentially playing in a preliminary final this week.

The core of the problem is the division between O’Neill and the coach, but the cracks at the club are threatening to grow. The players and the football department are on one side; O’Neill is on the other, with the support of the club’s executive.

It’s pointed criticism, implying that Arthur’s old-school approach won’t deliver the ultimate prize and end the club’s 34-year premiership drought.

The criticism of Arthur came at a sensitive time for the club as it dealt with the stunning positive drugs test for veteran centre Michael Jennings on the morning of last Saturday’s semi-final loss to the Rabbitohs. Jennings denies being a drug cheat and says he will fight to clear hisname.

The Eels think the next stage in their development will come from improving the team in a holistic sense. A major criticism of the Eels has been that they are fragile and get frazzled when the blowtorch is applied.

The club has done plenty of work in the area of mindfulness and mental strength. I had lengthy chats with Ryan Matterson this year about the work he did in that area and his approach has been adopted by other players.

Perhaps part of the issue here is that Arthur, while allowing this work to go on, wasn’t driving it. O’Neill is a big believer in courses and development. He is a disciple of a man named Shane McCurry, who has had success with Richmond in the AFL. McCurry is described as a “thought leader” and he clearly wants the Eels to be the Richmond Tigers of the NRL.

While Arthur is criticised for being too old-school and not taking on new ideas, O’Neill and the Eels football department are castigated throughout the NRL for being “too bureaucratic”. Their slow decision making and negotiating frustrates many. Managers say, along with Wests Tigers, they are the most cumbersome club to deal with.

Last year’s negotiations with club captainClint Gutherson were a case in point. Rightfully, Gutherson felt disrespected and he has proved himself to be their best player. It was not how their leader deserved to be treated and every signing the club makes is like pulling teeth.

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I was nodding my head reading this article until it criticised our negotiating with player agents. This is one area the club has improved upon dramatically. I'm sure the player Agents hate it which means their mates in the media also hate it. Which means it's precisely how we should be handling negotiations. 

    • I missed a paragraph in my copy paste. Sorry noob error

       

       

      No one at the club denies the Arthur-O’Neill rift – just the level of tension between the pair.
      O’Neill has been in his role for two years and, in fairness, the Eels have had considerable success in that time. But they now want a premiership and Arthur knows where the drive to change his approach is coming from.

      There was a line that got under his skin this week. “The team is not going to improve by doing another three laps of the oval,” an Eels official told me.

      • When was this article published?  I check both SMH & DT each morning, and I do not reccolect seeing it, especially in recent editions, would also like to know who the writer was to lend some credibility to it.

        If there is issues & I say IF between the coach & GM, I wonder if there is a repeat of why the GM left the Tigs after a shortish time.

        • Its another Genie Blog / Post. Lol Funny - well done "That Guy"

        • Danny weidler's column today. 

          • Wow i would of sworn it was a bull#&$# story. There you go. 👍

          • The Dunny Weasel and you guys are taking it seriously? Seriously?

            • Hahahha no still think its bull$&# news and a genie article, just got the author wrong. 

    • This reply was deleted.
    • Yes,  cumbersome aka not walkovers 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Grunta the great replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Talagi rejects player option, now on the open market
"The Eels are a shitshow and should have had Talagi secured some time ago, but if he wants to test the market I hope he goes...who cares?"
1 hour ago
adnan replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Talagi rejects player option, now on the open market
"I think he wanted ice.  I can understand reed going because I think he was the black sheep in the team.  I don't like O'Neil being there.  If there is tension between him and Arthur then one has to go. "
1 hour ago
adnan replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Talagi rejects player option, now on the open market
"Broken record you serial whinger"
1 hour ago
Hell On Eels replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Talagi rejects player option, now on the open market
"I hope so too, Analyst. And I'm worried too, buddy. Fingers crossed. "
2 hours ago
More…