Should we keep Kelma?

Unsure on his contract status but he's a damaging ball carrier lol. At worst he could come off our bench for punch 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • If he can defend like tonight then yes. 

  • For the hair alone 

  • He is playing for a contract. 1 year deals is the only thing I would consider and I still lean towards no

    • Would be ok with a 1-2 year deal yeah. Definitely worth keeping if he's happy to stick around 

      • I think Kelma could be developed into a front row if we don't resign Junior. Keep his game simple. He has more upside than Morretti. 

        • Kelma in the front row? It probably takes a unique kind of mind to either willingly run full tilt at or get in front of charging props, given the giant proportions of many props. Kelma's role has been to terrorize halves defending on the edge and he does that well. But I wouldn't call Kelma a fearsome middle defender. Could he transition?

    • always handy to have some depth in the pack he'd at least come off the bench once we got sua 

    • This.

      You know what Tuilagi is we don't dedicate any long term money or years to a guy who basically is a bridge to the next guy.Tuilagi if he left next year I'm telling you now I'm not losing any sleep.

      Dylan Brown I'm still having nightmares about.

      Thats the sought of talent we have let go the last 12-18 months and haven't replaced it that's the train wreck.

      Should we keep Tuilagi I mean seriously folks get a farken grip 😂 

  • He has always been good in attack, it's his defence that let's him down. The worst thing about it is it's an easy fix, it's a technique issue. He plants his feet early than leans sideways (depending which way the ball carrier goes) and only uses his upper body strength in the tackle,  with your legs not set underneath you that is never going to be good enough in first grade. 

    • Bingo. The planting of his feet is his biggest issue. I've seen him have some fantastic defensive games yet whe he's bad he's very bad

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Jack replied to Trev's discussion U19 origin
"Thank badger, hope ya well mate. I met you a few times over the years. You use to know my sister jasmine. She use to work at one of the pubs at Newtown if you remember "
46 seconds ago
Parra-all-the-way replied to Trev's discussion U19 origin
"Fingers crossed he see's his future in blue and gold! Sounds a real wing prospect from all reports. "
3 minutes ago
Parra-all-the-way replied to Trev's discussion U19 origin
"Thanks mate"
5 minutes ago
Parra_Greg replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Denis Fitzgerald (AKA The Emperor) enjoys a fortified
"3P man Id blocked that period Steve Sharp, Ray spagnolo, Paulo Osbourne, et al .....I remember some on here going balistic on this group lol.   wonder if Stevie picked up the tools again after.......3P was just old boys sniffing around for a payment…"
36 minutes ago
More…