I'm sure not everyone will agree but in my personal opinion Set Restarts in particular are destroying the game and allowing the referee to basically control the outcome of games. Combine the Set Restarts with diabolical refereeing and bunker calls then the whole fairness of Rugby League has long gone. Seriously today's game was disgraceful refereeing ( yes the Eels made some poor mistakes and the younger players are still learning) but a 10-1 penalty count and not 1 repeat set 🤣. This seems to be a continual report on 85% of refereeing of the Eels games. In my opinion the Eels hierarchy need to speak up about the appalling referee and bunker calls. It's not only the Eels coping it but it seems the lower placed teams get the raw end of the stick. Ricky Stuart isn't afraid of speaking up when things go against his team with refs. About time the Eels did the same or they'll continue to be the NRL doormat team
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
Replies
Seraph,
Discrimating between hate, criticism and analysis was about "us". Humans. The media. Me too. Not just you.
One, there's never been a claim from me you're "egregarious" , a "click baiter" or a club "hater".
Some of your posts are voracious criticisms of the club (I have been critical at times too) but criticism in cyber space is more commonplace than farts. Meh. I expect it. Still, it probably helps the site as I implied in my earlier more generalized post which you falsely interpreted as an attack on you. Maybe my writing style might need some tune ups.
Two, it's common practice for clubs to advertise for positions such as senior performance coaches — would you agree? It's not as big deal as you are making it out to be — a sign of incompetence and used perjoratively as how we need to strike luck to land a new "super coach".
Three, in principle, it's unwise to keep players or club employees on the club's dime that whinge and moan too much and aren't really on the bus, biting the hand that feeds them. Erodes morale and is white anting.
I don't have an issue with you Seraph. You're good for the site. Just disagree on those three points or ideas — which we can agree to disagree on.
You could very well have correct information from your sources but I guess time will tell. Nothing has been leaked from the media as yet and they're usually the first mob to sniff out any inner turmoil especially with Parra. I'd be surprised if there's anything in this other than Mills missing his expertise in areas he's more trained and experienced in within Rugby Union
Maybe he's more used to Rugby Union more than League. There could be many reasons he's leaving if he actually is..I'm sure Ryles will have someone better lined up
Well now his role I am not familiar with and how much they do with players. Though I am curious to know if he mishandled Moses in pre-season this year? Moses' foot was a reaggrevation of his broken toe from the screw due to heavy load.
Now I am happy to say I could be way off as that role is out of my field of knowledge to be fair.
But you seeded the idea LB.
I know i did.
Blair's from New Zealand. He's heading home.
X a million billion
this
eels need to get vocal and ask for meetings with referee bosses showing our concerns around decisions
Thats more than likely a queue for that meeting with the other 7 teams that lost this round Carlo.
I think the rules themselves need to be looked at and that will help take away the subjectiveness of the opinions that refs give.
There is no doubt that different referees have different intepretations over the same rules and I have no doubt that the side they give momentum to ultimately wins the game. Big name players also have an influence, Cam Smith being the obvious standout but I think the refs get a bit starstruck as well. I'll maintain that this comes back to incompetence and performance anxiety rather than corruption, the way Austrac monitors the gaming side of things, you can guarantee anyone related to big wins would be investigated and the corporate and state betting fraternities are paranoid about it.
One final offer I would make is that we need someone to take an overview of refereeing outside of another ref. Someone influential to talk about the rules, intepretation and the role of things like the six again. i.e six again was brought in to keep the game flowing and stoppages for penalties. I think it would be fair to say if six again's were stopped the game would slow but there needs to be a balance in the process.
Referees by nature are junior policeman and seem to lack the necessary ability to "play on" and make judgements about different indescretions. The knock on rules, high catches,play the balls and forward passes having tweaks could eliminate the pedantic needs to keep giving 6 agains. It is always a matter of commonsense and commonsense needs to be added to the rule book.
It's just a way for the nrl to control who they want to give an upper hand to. All very vague calls with no explanation. Roll ball is the same.
-
8
-
9
-
10
-
11
-
12
of 16 Next