SEMI's ERROR

After Round 1, I was awestruck by the power and speed of this bloke, and I still am to a degree.

But last night was a harsh reminder of his other side. We all saw it. Jarryd saw it. And all our reactions were the same. I wanted to strangle him: "Why you little......"

Semi will continue to make some shocking mistakes. He'll be tested alot under the high ball and he'll fail many times, especially against the better teams that exploit his weaknesses. He'll lose the ball at crucial times.  Truly rocks and diamonds.

Are we better off to drop Semi back to reserves while he fine tunes the finer aspects of his game? Or do we persist with him in the hope there are more diamonds than rocks?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I say keep him in first grade. That's where you pay to  learn and the price is embarrassing errors. 

  • Its a very fine line ih8 Manly.
    In my opinion we should persevere with Semi on he's try scoring and tackle breaking ability alone.

    However we cannot cover for two inexperienced wingers.

    So it's TATA Toutai- Hello Hunt.
  • long term I see him turning into a center
  • He's scored 4 tries in 2 games. I'd say Toutai's position is under a little more pressure at the moment.

  • Yeah it was one error, it happens to the best players, but some more than others,
  • keep him hes our top point scorer with him the cocks would of beat us 56to 0 with him

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to Yehez's discussion Sarantinos on the Tip Sheet
"Could Lachlan Vella be one? I haven't seen him much this year but he had raps on him."
5 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Electric Eel 2's discussion Recruitment and Retention and signings
"Bluey. 
"I have zero confidence though that our recruitment team can negotiate and close a deal for a player that is wanted by other clubs."
This begs a response in that yes, our recruitment team is average from a charismatic point of view. Also …"
8 minutes ago
LB replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Team List: Round 16 V Titans
"Lol good point Mutts. He is seen as a god and knows what is happening, i think he does, but Brown signing and possibly losing Ponga is not great on his resume. "
8 minutes ago
LB replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Team List: Round 16 V Titans
"But at the same time Titans have had most of that experience and still lost a lot of games. Not saying 100% we win but by 30+?
I mean if we do i will come back and apologise but i do not see it that much."
11 minutes ago
More…