Sandon Smith or Jack Cole

I think Sandon wont come to us as he be thinking he our 2rd choice but as they said on NRL360 Hes a good player and he will leave now if a NRL spot came up and its just down road so not far from home 

And getting one back off panthers 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • How do you know he was our second choice?

    • Well it is apparent we wanted Galvin, we made that known. Now going for Smith due to missing out.

      • Who's Saying we didn't go for Sandon Smith first?

        Why do people believe everything reporters are talking bs

        So a club can't have made offers to multiple players at the same time?

        • Surely you don't believe MON is smart enough, or has the strategical acumen to have been chasing Smith all along?  

        • 😂 because our clubs always late to the party chief much like yourself it has to be smacking them in the face before they have any sought of foward thought.

          Let me guess you still think those dopes picked JR over Bennett don't you 🤣 

          • They lucky with sandon smith he can't really do anything until the dce deal is finalised so he's in a holding pattern 😂 they are really slow decision making wise 

        • I mean is it possible? Perhaps, but very unlikely. If we weren't so public with our interest in Galvin i would believe it. But you are saying Chris Orr, Smith's manager, would have happily let Sandon negotiate with a strong possibility he would not be at Parramatta with Galvin in the mix? If both Smith and Galvin agreed, who are we taking?

          Orr would have said either you talk to my client or we go elsewhere. Not like hiring a coach where 10 coaches go for one job, there are 16 other teams Smith could go. 

          If you said they had some discussions with Smith before Galvin, then they re-entered talks post Galvin i could believe that.

  • Neither of them are needed, we have Joash, Talatiana and Apa Twiddle, all of them can do a job at 6 next to Moses. Save the money and bolster the forward pack. Maybe even another strike outside back. 

    • Doesn't seem that way though Sterlo. Us going for Galvin then now apparently Smith shows Ryles wants someone else at 6. I said similar about Hooker as Brailey was chased then Starling.

      • I agree with Sterlo, promote from within. Look at the outcomes with Tuivaiti and Smith!

        These young blokes just need an opportunity. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion NRL THREATEN 10-YEAR BAN FOR R360 DEFECTORS
"Nah Pou is right, RCG still had to agree to come to Parramatta. He had a contract and was free to stay at Penrith if he liked, he would just play NSW Cup."
29 minutes ago
Michael W. replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion NRL THREATEN 10-YEAR BAN FOR R360 DEFECTORS
"R360 wants to work, they will do everything within their power to make it succeed. God help the NRL if it does succeed."
6 hours ago
Michael W. replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion NRL THREATEN 10-YEAR BAN FOR R360 DEFECTORS
"That's total crap Pou, RCG had a 5yr contract with Penrith, he was told he wasn't wanted, same with Waqa Blake. How many players are in a similar situation, their previous club paying part of their salary at another club. This is how clubs offload…"
6 hours ago
Poupou Escobar replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion NRL THREATEN 10-YEAR BAN FOR R360 DEFECTORS
"Nobody is offloaded mid contract unless they agree to it, which is why Matterson and Hands are still at the club. All the players who did leave or retire chose to."
8 hours ago
More…