Questions about Hayne's injury

For anyone that hasn't heard, Hayne is out for the remainder of the season with a grade three tear to his medial ligament in his knee therefore requiring surgery tomorrow. With the news that he requires surgery I was thinking about when Hayne hurt his knee during the warriors game and afterwards Phil Gould came out saying Hayne told him that he needed surgery. After this was publicized and became a big deal Hayne and the parramatta organisation were very vocal in saying he doesn't need surgery.

Does anyone else think Hayne and the crew at the eels all knew how risky it was for him to keep playing and that he required surgery all along and just didn't want people to know so he could keep playing? Or am I thinking into this too much? Could they have seriously let him keep playing injured like that just for the sake of winning? 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • No it was an entirely different injury. Having said that if was still not 100 percent with his ankle injury it is quite common to do another injury as your body tries to compensate. It is just one of those things unfortunately. If you waited for a player to be 100 percent you could be waiting all day. We needed Hayne on the park ASAP and we got the result we wanted. Just unlucky!
    • I do definitely agree with your comments about over compensation, but are you sure it was a different injury? I remember it always being the right knee, and he did his right knee.

  • I have said often that we must have the worst team doctor... Probably one of spagnolo bolagnaise's mates knowing our club...
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Poppa replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner....He who is without sin, cast the first stone, so says the brethern LOL
"Good research Chiefy....excellent actually
It seems that JAC is doing all the right things, its probably only the second offence that is going to stop him...I imagine.
PS Don't let the mob know you are using AI as a search tool....they don't like…"
3 minutes ago
LB replied to Johnny Suede's discussion The Mole (yeah, I know!) says Parra chasing Cowboys' Jeremiah Nanai
"It makes me wonder what the plan is. We have Petrus coming through, despite PNG connection you should plan with the intention that he is a 10 year player for us. Williams you'd expect we would want to keep and Su'A signed til 2029. So is it like…"
16 minutes ago
Mannah-Brow replied to Johnny Suede's discussion The Mole (yeah, I know!) says Parra chasing Cowboys' Jeremiah Nanai
"Maybe we are looking at transitioning Sua into a middle like souths did with Kelma. He is big, mobile and aggressive. I think he would be a good fit there anyway and even without Nanai would swap him in there and Spencer and move Williams to the…"
23 minutes ago
Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner....He who is without sin, cast the first stone, so says the brethern LOL


The Incident: Trindall was pulled over by police in Caringbah the morning after a game. He returned a mid-range blood alcohol reading of 0.125 and tested positive for an illicit substance, which was later confirmed to be cocaine. He was also…"
30 minutes ago
More…