Quality signings

Not including coaches. When was the last time the eels were able to sign a quality rep player at the peak of his powers. Hoppa doesn't count because of his sabatical. Do we have to go back to Edge. Why can't we ever sign anyone of note. I'm itching for us to sign foran for 2016 but our track record suggests if they don't come through our juniors we don't sign them. It's an issue at present time we need to rectify.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Sandow and Tonga were massive signings for the club. And we all know how that turned out.
  • What are you talking about, Cody Nelson ring a bell?

    Hello, what about Shannan McPherson?

  • This reply was deleted.
    • McCracken , Pay , Smith ,and Dymock were a result of the super league war. Probally the best signings we've made in two decades. But I'm talking about buying one of the best players in the comp. I know all four were good players but I'm talking an Inglis, lockyer, Johns, Thurston, C Smith, Fittler.We never seem to be Inthe hunt.
    • Morrison?

  • You could pretty much ask that of any club. There have only been a handful of rep signings of any club that have gone on to bigger and better things.
    Some of the big signings who have done well include Inglis, jennings, Bird.
    look at the failures though Dave Taylor, Barba, Tonga, Boyd, Hannant.

    There are only a Handful of genuine superstars in the game and they are mostly homegrown
  • You could argue after just winning a comp and being rep players McCracken pay and smith would be. Timana tahu was a automatic selection for nsw when we signed him first time.
    In the last 5 years no one.
  • Justin Poore was a rep player when we signed him. We all thought he'd be good. He just failed to deliver.

  • Nothing on zero tackle worth signing.
  • The end of 2004 was the last time this was done successfully after missing the finals for a 2nd straight year. BS bought in Riddell, Tahu, Morrison, Marsh and we won the minor premiership the following year .
  • Long time between drinks
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Poppa replied to Joel K's discussion Credit to the bench
"The defensive issue is in the halves, Pezet was a turnstyle in that period and our defence misshapen, it was only after Haas went off that we regained any rythm.....Moses was also trying to be everywhere and ended up nowhere, clutching air a lot.…"
4 minutes ago
SuperEel 22 replied to Roy tannous's discussion Jdb junior paulo 👉🚪👋
"JDB had the highest tackle efficiency of any Eels player at 95%. That's basically his job. Make the tackles in the middle in the opening 20 minutes."
15 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Joel K's discussion Credit to the bench
"Keep him where he is, let him grow into the role, he will get his chance, why lose the momentum he brings, same as Walker."
15 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Joel K's discussion Credit to the bench
"Not to mention not falling off Haas, something that is not easy to do."
18 minutes ago
More…