Push or Shove?

Can anyone explain why

1. Earlier in the year Fergo was running for a high ball and pushed a blocker out the way, knocked the ball back to Waqa (or Matterson I forget) and who scored but was the try was disallowed and Fergo penalised for pushing the blocker off the ball.

2. Today a Tigers player was running at the Manly defender positioned to catch a bomb and pushed him out the way. The Tigers player had no eyes for the ball. The Manly defender partially recovered and attempted to catch the ball uncontested but knocked on. No penalty and the scrum from the knock on ended up in the Tiger's try.

How is Fergo's push a penalty and the Tigers not?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

More stuff to read

Mick aka Big Chris replied to EelsAgeMe's discussion Haven’t commented here for a while. Good to see we’re still a dumb team.,
"Whats my type?? Someone that disagrees with your opinion or perspective? Anyway, we see things differently and if you think you can stand over me behind a screen?? Its Not happening. "
57 minutes ago
Mick aka Big Chris replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Club needs to step in on the Moses representative situation
"Good blog BUT I disagree mate, we need more players playing rep footy at every level especially SOO - SOO is for elite players and this the very reason why Moses excels. Although we won our last comp in 86 Australia and NSW teams were stacked with…"
1 hour ago
Hell On Eels replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Club needs to step in on the Moses representative situation
"Randy,  An interesting one.
I suppose coaches trust certain players or believe they're the best fit for the team, even if club form or a high minute count aren't there.
I'd choose you for x-factor even if you only had 5 minutes of form."
3 hours ago
Randy Handlinger replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Club needs to step in on the Moses representative situation
"Hoe, I dislike the idea that a player can be selected for Aust with only 480 club minutes on show...and not all of them good. How can he have form without playing?
Perhaps a rule that said 10 nrl games to be eligible for Aust would help everyone"
3 hours ago
More…