- Iongi - great game. Ran hard with his footwork. Solid under the high ball. Real player off the future.
- Russel - Moved to centre and defended very well as he has recently. But unfortunately today his catch and pass went missing on 2 occassions. Its a necessity that a outside back can do it in the modern game. At the end of the day he is a onlya depth outside back so he did his job.
- Penisni - n/a
- Samrani - as you can see he struggled a bit in defence due to inexperience in the NRL and with the players around him. Hard to judge him hard when he is being moved into the backrow long term too. His runs our strong.
- JAC - unfortunately did not get good ball but did his job in defence and yardage.
- Brown - As the game went on his involvement died down. His defence was solid on Olaktaou.
- Hawkins - Does have the best high kick but managed the team well and still kicked well. Great pass for that try too. Great to have a halfback capable of filling in for Moses.
- Paulo - Real captain knock in his miestone game. Been great recently. 207m and 64min. Only 1 offload which shows the real run firt mentality.
- Smit - Did not overplay his hand either. Tackles and provides kick pressure all night long.
- Moretti - Bit a of brain fart to kick the ball after stripping it. He obviously suits the bench impact role but was fine starting.
- Kautoga - I cannot believe how much he has developed since round 1. He looks more the first grader each week and dominated Olaktou today. No errors or penalties. 4 missed tackles but nothing crucial.
- Wiliams - big motor and was great in attack and defence. 5 missed tackles but again nothing crucial.
- Hopgood - a better game today but still errors. Hope that flukey try gives him some confidence. Effort is not the issue for him. ITs concentration
- Walker - one of the best signings of the year and arguably the best mid season signings ever. His ball playing is simply elite.
- Matto - Did his job. I prefer him starting and Moretti off the bench. Matto has lost his impact and is more someone to absorb the collision at the start.
- Tuilagi - Ran hard but still plants his feet while sliding in defence. At full strenth Samrani should drop back onto the bench with Tuilagi in reggies.
- Papalii - obviously struggled in defence in the first half which is understandable. Never trained or played on the wing this year and with new combinations inside of him. Samrani and Hawkins are slow too which makes it harder to trust them in coming across in defence. FIxed it in the second half. Everyoen can see his footy smarts and footwork in attack.
Coaching Staff:
Have to applaud JR. The new style we are playing is great. Spreading the ball in attack and new defensive structures. He clearly spoke to that edge defence during HT and they improved which shows signs that he is a good coach. The other thing is shows which is across this team is that we have a lot of quick learners. Smith, Iongi and Kautofa have improved so much since round 1 this year. Testament to both players and coaching staff involved.
Replies
Also Corryn will be happy to see we finally had a good completion rate for once.
All round performance was really good tonight I couldn't think of one facet of the game where Manly were better.We owned them across the board.
Good to see growth in the team and new players stepping up.
Im starting to like kautoa love hes work rate and hes off loads in tackles and I think it was Moretti who made that big run up the middle he had a great to
JR is showing a lot of smarts in how he coaches and how he speaks.
All did well but I am gonna harp on Kautoga this whole coming week.
I wanted him dropped after the tigers game in round 7 despite us winning. Just not first grade standard.
He's been a beast past 3 games.
Great review EA once again!
Our team, which included a lot of inexperience, played as a team friday nite and it was great to see. For too long we have played as a group of individuals.
Russell as we all can see is very ordinary in attack but wow hasn't he improved his defence. I feel if he continues in to improve in this manner, thru the supreme amount of confidence he must be gaining, he will become a great defender.
It may even make him improve in attack.
What about Williams, what a surprise packet he's become. I never rated him before and wasn't the least bit enthused when he came to us, even though Gallen spoke glowingly of him. But now he's shocked me out of my Japanese sea-boots. He'll be so confident now in his ability that the sky's the limit.
By the way EA did you watch the cup game this morning. If so, did you sense a little bias from the guy calling the game?
EA i have not been reading these summaries that you have done here. How long have you been doing them?
Love seeing the context of summary and be ready I will tell you if I disagree, but I know you would expect nothing less.
Couple of things, I believe that Hopgood had an excellent game, the best he has shown this year. In saying that he has and still is doing an enormous amount of thankless defence which goes unseen, as against the dropped balls which are highlighted and threatening of beheadings, the critic's on here are totally unforgiving and mostly poor judges..
I would also question missed tackles which can be so subjective. I would prefer to see "full misses's recorded" rather than just missed tackles. which are meaningless without context. Tullagi may plant his feet and I am well aware of his problems using lateral movement, but he had a great game with post contact metres that wasn't brought out in your summary. Williams was always a talent and it is no surprise to me that its showing through. I was more surprised how quiet he was in the early rounds and maybe there was an injury being the reason pre season.
You have probably noticed how TCT do grades.....is there a possibility you could do something similar in numbers plus and minus notations? If you did set this up on a "template" it could be a standard Monday Morning Gradings that would become legendary on here. Earler if we have a Thursday/Friday game, that would be your call.
I am sure that Hoey would help you with the template, i.e. you could have the 18 players set out, A number for the grade in a different colour, and a written section against each player.
Apart from being a pain in the arse to do all that, you should also be ready for the criticism you will cop with the "idiots" disagreeing, myself being no exception. I have given the boys from TCT some terrible comments on their judgements at times, mostly not I might add.
Over to you mate, it would really enhance the site.
EA'S PLAYER PERFORMANCE RATINGS