NRL Charges

What does it take to be sent off. A classic from last nights game is the tackle on Lane verses Sivo. Sivo a fine and the 2 Manly players get 2 weeks each. How does Parramatta benefit from this? The teams advantaged are the teams Manly play over the next week and the team disadvantaged is Parramatta. Cleary Sivo was dumb but should not have been binned. Also Penisini should not have been binned because Turbo was in front of the kicker. Brown was also called not square when clearly he was square. Manly players where also driving with the head in tackles and getting away with it. Another classic of why a fullback should not be sin binned. How Cherry Evans was not binned for back chat shows me why the captain should be a front line player.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Dylbags was dumb for playing at the hookers arm, this is always called a penalty, Hayne used to do it all the time and it was a penalty every time. 

    For the record Hayne was square when he did it and so was Dylbags on the weekend. 

    • Yep he was square. The refs eyes could not keep up with the play. I refuse to believe he was cheating. It's too simple to say that. I think they just aren't mentally capable of keeping up with the speed of the game. It's beyond them. It's beyond anyone. Even our "expert" commentators need replays all the time before they comment and they literally watch footy for a living. In such a scenario a bad ref will ref in a direction. It's suttle and hard to pick but it's there. I see it in many games.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to LB's discussion Report: De Belin dropped for poor form
"We were desperate for a back with experience. Kelly presented himself as an option and we took a punt. Recruitment you never strike 100%. If anything i think the number is more 40% is the strike rate for decent teams. 
I will say for Kelly, he had a…"
29 seconds ago
LB replied to LB's discussion Report: De Belin dropped for poor form
"Kelly i believe we all agreed would be nice depth incase of injury, maybe keep Penisini and Russell looking over their shoulder. But with Samrani practically jumping Kelly, it looks like a dud. Those happen, but good on Ryles for keeping standards…"
6 minutes ago
LB replied to LB's discussion Report: De Belin dropped for poor form
"When you have a 6 man bench you do not 100% know who will play to be fair EA. He could have simply named them in certain numbers based on what they were prior anyway. "
8 minutes ago
LB replied to LB's discussion Report: De Belin dropped for poor form
"Well it could have been he was planned for the 17 and is on the bench to find a spot. Some thought it could be he is just moved to the bench."
10 minutes ago
More…