Most impressive and disappointing: Round 16 v Rabbitohs

It is becoming habit of; W, L, W, L for us this season. Yet funnily enough we have yet to lose two straight this season. With upcoming games against Wests and NZ Warriors, matches where we would be favourites. Now where do we stand? Well i wrote a blog last week or so, simply saying Souths would be smarting, they will want to avenge the embarrassing performance against St. George Illawarra, while we seem to go into "we are all good now" mode after a great performance, relying on talent and quality to get us the rest of the way, it is a merry-go-round of events. Unlike the Canterbury loss, this one was not as embarrassing, more so it was expected. Only 46% possession which is not good at all, 70% completions. In the first half we had 0 tackle breaks, ending the game with 18. Only 4 offloads, weather caused that, 5 to 1 forced drop outs which shows our creativity on the 5th, 33 missed tackles to their 18. Another different note to mention is that we currently have the 9th best defence in the league right now, 9 teams have conceaded less points than us this year, that is not acceptable considering we were expected to be near top 4 and having a roster overhaul next year in terms of our starting 17. Though they had one more error than us, showing we did not take advantage of the ball when having it.


Most Impressive: 

Ky Rodwell: No man of the match for me this week, however Rodwell was not too bad. Early on had a few meh runs and missed tackles but quickly adjusted and look decent in the middle. No signs of yet to show he will be a full-time member of the 17 moving forward. 6 runs for 60 metres and 25 tackles rounded up a nice 25mins for Ky.

Oregon Kaufusi: A decent performance from Oggy, 167 metres, understanding the assignment of running hard through the middle in this weather. Hot and cold season from Oggy but tonight he was good off the bench.


Most Disappointing: 

Makahesi Makatoa: Not sure from everyone else, but he looked overmatched. He did not really offer much impact off the bench, and is disappointing considering how well he played in the trials. 20 games now and he has not really had a performance this year that makes you say "That is why he is named every week". Signed til 2024, so hopefully can improve but fear he may be just a squad player for us.

Reed Mahoney: He seems to be trying somewhat, but seems to have his mind on the paycheck at Belmore at the moment. If i were Canterbury fans, i would feel a little bit confused on whether Mahoney in for JMK is such a good thing, especially for 650K. The kick that landed straight into Johnston's chest, though kicks like that needed to happen more, it was poor. No running, 1 run for 10 metres, unlike last year where he was running, only 3 try assists this year compared to this time last year where he was on double digits. 51 tackles with 6 missed, including a turnstile for Latrell. Reed has not had a good 2022, honestly it seems we made the right choice moving on.

Maiak Sivo: Forgot he played, only 9 runs, enough said.

Will Penisini: This kid will have a nice career, i am sure of that. Tonight however was not his best, Isaiah Tass and Alex Johnston had his number along with Simonsson numerous times. Still a young kid there is room to grow, look at Jennings, early in his career he was criticised as being an average defender, then became the best defensive centre in the NRL, but looked all over the place tonight.

Mitchell Moses: Well been a while before he has been truly awful, only 4 runs, when Mitch runs we do well. Kicking wise this game and it's conditions suited how he boots a football yet not there. Tried to hard to have us score on every play, including that stupid tip on intercepted by Johnston. Needs to take control more, instead just argues with the ref on every little call, move on and focus on your team instead of a wrong call.

Brad Arthur: Ok i will write a blog about him later, i know people here will be like please don't more so due to me writing not so much the topic, but man he needs to clarify things better. Coming out of what i suggested was his best press conference since becoming coach in 2014 a fortnight ago, to well what he dished up last night. Just looked a bit confused and contridicting himself. Claiming effort was there yet claims some players need to give more, plus the catchphrases return "Effort was there", to "Front load effort" to now "We need to play the footy we want to play" but now Gutho speaks it for him, might thinks it sounds better if not him saying it. The bench is weird and wacky, honestly JA would have made more sense being on the bench than Opacic, i know the 17th player hardly gets minutes as it is, but why give Paulo a 10 min spell to bring him back on again before halftime? Why not use that time at halftime to rest him up a bit more?


Another week and another "Where to next". Wests at Leichhardt, we will be favourites but Wests just lost 22-2 to the Warriors, so maybe Brooks is dropped and they fire up at Leichhardt where they have done well at this year. Changes, well Paulo will be out due to Origin, so Kaufusi will start at his expense. Matterson could be back meaning Niukore moves back to the bench with Opacic moving out for maybe JA, Greig or Cartwright.

If Matto is still out Niukore will start of course, bench could be Makatoa, Greig, Rodwell, Cartwright.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –


  • Could have made the blog a little shorter LB by making it a most disappointing blog only as there was absolutely nothing impressive from Parra in that game.

    • Practically did that after the Canterbury performance.

  • Gutherson and Lane excluded , you could've just put up this years team photo under most disappointing this week.  Moses was totally pathetic .  To think he earnt about 40k for that game.  No excuse for him having a shit week on that kinda coin. 

    • Gutherson made some bad mistakes with the kicks and some defense too.

      Agreed, Lane was probably our best. I've always said the Lane Train was underrated. He is a popular punching bag on the fan sites but he is having a better season than most of our guys.

      Agreed Moses needs more scrutiny. I find in these games where we panic - it should be the halfback settling us down but he does not have that trait. He panics and the team panics with him.

      • Gutherson made a dumb error at the scrum and a few bad reads , but overall I thought he had a dig.  Moses problem isn't ability , it's consistency. He's a protected species on here and in the media.   When people have to refer to a Newcastle game last year to give an example of Moses owning a game , then you have a serious problem. 

        We really miss Fergos leadership qualities on the paddock.  Game like last nights Fergo would've sparked it up with a run against the flow . 

        • I always stood up for Fergo too. How many people couldn't wait until Fergo left? But replacing him with Bailey is a poor imitation of the kind of grit that Ferguson has. Fergo changed our team when he arrived in 2019. He is a huge loss. Totally with you on that. He embodies a kind of grit and determination that we lack right now.

          I'm with you on Moses too. I can list other games he took over - but most are against poor opposition. Broncos final in 2019 comes to mind. Dragons 2022 game. Tigers 2021. There are others - but he needs to do it more often and against better teams.

          Agreed, Gutherson had a dig. Still some silly kicks though.

          • Im sure theres other games , especially if we are needing to go back to 2019 , let's say for arguments sake we double the games you've noted , he'll let's triple it .  As a halfback it's simply not enough to be owning 2 or 3 games a year in a top 8 team.  Especially at his age .  He's now getting to the stage wheras he'll be overtaken by rookies coming through at other clubs.  This time next year he'll probs be behind Nico Hynes on the origin halfback options pecking order . 

            • Surely Nicho is ahead of him right now. Nicho's team won and Moses' lost. Nicho took 18 runs and Moses took 4. I think Moses just needs to run it more. He must be carrying a leg injury. I think Reed is busted too because he's missing tackles and only took 1 run. Both are either playing injured, or playing bad.

              Gutho with 12 runs was outplayed by Latrell who took 17 too.

              • He probably is behind him now.  I guess there'd still be a debate if Cleary went down and they needed a replacement. You'd have the Benny Elias mates in the media saying how Moses should be there , then you'd have the rest saying Hynes is a better option.  This time next year Moses won't even be a mention at this rate . Truth is he will probably be 3rd or 4th option this time next year unless he pulls his finger out. 

        • Mitch Moses a protected species ?

          Are you kidding ?

          Other than Luke Brooks I can't think of another player more heavily criticised in the media and by the public than Mitch Moses. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

BrAd '9 years' ArThUr replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Trent Barrett joins Eels as Assistant Coach in 2023
"So does an assistant have any say, or do they just carry out the coach's game plans?"
7 minutes ago
Parra-all-the-way replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Trent Barrett joins Eels as Assistant Coach in 2023
"100%! as an assistant he was cleary successful, coming from the panthers system. Sometimes a good assistant doesnt not make a good coach. I think it is a smart move to bring new blood in, esp when they have come from a good system."
8 minutes ago
BrAd '9 years' ArThUr replied to BEM's discussion New side enters the race for Trent Barrett
"I remember last year Sterlo schooling BA on using the sideline as an additional defender. 8 years and still couldn't figure that out. "
9 minutes ago
Muttman replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Trent Barrett joins Eels as Assistant Coach in 2023
"I'd never cheer for Parra to lose any game. But unfortunately I do see some benefits to the Eels missing the 8 this year. We can't afford more of the same. "
10 minutes ago