Morgan vs Hoppa

There is no doubt about it Hoppa will be a special player however I am starting to think Morgan has more to offer. Hoppa is able to put his winger over the line but has problems finding the try line himself. Morgan however seems to find the try line every game. Do we need to play Morgan over Hoppa or Tonga? To me Morgan must be starting. Thoughts?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Morgan's D ...has also stepped up...he would be my 1st choice...then Hoppa....Willie although playing solid...would drop off...

  • Hoppa is a class above Morgan but I've always rated Morgan. He's got guts and he has a go. Hoppa's biggest problem is probably his best asset; his placid professionalism. Hoppa's tough but he hasn't got much mongrel in him if you ask me. Morgans has 2 options the way I see it, he can wait and hope to take over from Tonga or he can shop himself to other clubs but he won't get a starting spot over Tonga or Hoppa.
  • He is impressive but where do play him. Hoppa must play, maybe we release tonga next year.
  • ILL  have both .drop Tonga

  • Morgan over tonga
  • Hated Tonga's game today..he looked uninterested from the start.

    Morgan for Tonga.

  • Morgan consistently beats his man when he has room.

    I like that.

  • Hoppa is an excellent dummy half runner & Morgan would probably be the worst centre in the Nrl at it
  • There is no substitute for speed & Morgs has it. Been impressed with him the 2 games played now & good defence also.

  • It depends on which aspects you look at it. Morgan definitely offers more in attack as a solo runner and bringing it out of our half, but hoppa has softer hands. Ion defence there on about par, I'd probably just rate morgan over hoppa as when Morgan does miss tackles, he always slows them down or he drops off just before the tackle is complete whilst hoppa is fended off a lot. Both are first grade players, tonga should be dropped, he offers nothing when he doesn't have a lot of space and the opposition has read him really well I. The second half of our season so far. It's crazy when you think if reports are correct, hoppa is on close to about three times more than Morgan and he doesn't offer much more (hoppa apparently 750-850 a year, morgs 250 a year).
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Parra fan on The Hill replied to Offside's discussion Samrani vs Penisini
"Other way round if it were to be. Penisini is too slow for the wing. 
Wouldnt drop Simo. His hit ups are good and he works hard.
Anyway..Samrani 1st drop for injuries or suspensions. Not bog average Brian Kelly.
 "
20 minutes ago
paul taylor replied to Offside's discussion Samrani vs Penisini
"With over 100 nrl games in difference with samrani and will P .  I like samrani puts himself in the game and has a physical presence about it. Will has definitely worked on increasing his pace and defence but Samrani not that far behind him now . "
25 minutes ago
Offside replied to Offside's discussion Samrani vs Penisini
"Definitely more time is needed to make a judgement call but I hope some actual competition for his spot. "
33 minutes ago
Webby replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Your Team list v Dragons - Kelma must stay
"Good looking side zip zip"
43 minutes ago
More…