Manakafoua or Horo

Ok , firstly if there was any positives from today, i thought it was the perfomance of Manakafoua (not sure how to spell his name). He didn't set the world on fire, but i thought he did a very good job out there and i think he will be a very valuable pick up, knowing we have abit more depth now. Personally ,  i'd have him in our team any day. The big question is who misses out for him, i know lots of people like Justin Horo on this site, but lets be honest, he started very well, and since has done nothing, while his efforts have been admiral and solid, i think we would gain more from Manakafoua coming of the bench, Horo looks abit lost in defense where Manase looked alot more solid.

 

Anyway, thoughts?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Personally the only one that played well today was "sparkie" ????
  • you have to kidding???..

    Justin Horo makes this guy look like a park footballer.
    • lol, he is a park footballer, so is Horo, remember, horo wouldnt have a minute under his belt if Shacks never got injured, i just think Manase will offer more in the long run. anyway just my opinion, ur entitled to urs im entitled to mine
  • Horo had a shocker today - thats the kind of shit he used to hand in occasionally at Wenty, especially that defensive miss, and why I never thought he'd make it in first grade.

    But that was one game in ten. He's been out shining light this year and hopefully he learns from it. Manase didn't wrap me. From my memory of him playing for Souths he was more explosive than that - but maybe it was just the wet.
  • To be honest, neither of them ! They can fight out for the 18th spot and I would choose Horo.

    How we miss Todd Lowrie !
    • GOlling you don't think Horo has been good prior to this game? Lowrie, spare me!
  • *Waits for Lowrie bashers to come* Come on guys! Let's all gang up on Toddy!

    On a serious note though I was shocked by Horo's bad game. Let's sign him up now! He'll be much cheaper lol.
  • I'll have them both in the team. Horo had one bad game this year. He has been a gun all year and a future leader of our forwards along with Poore, Mannah, Smith etc. He has got all the attributes of a good solid 1st grader. Manase is solid like Moi Moi was when he started with us and with a bit of more game time with us and self belief he will develop into the next Moi Moi. Remember DA hates lazy footballers and if he thought Manase was lazy he would never have signed him. I really rate them both and was happy when the news that we signed Manase came through. Wasted at the cowboys and rabbits. Watch him develop at the eels.
  • P.S. Never rate Lowrie and still don't rate him.................
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Tallyn Debut
"650k???
For that money, he better be starting."
33 minutes ago
EA replied to Anthony Mara's discussion Sam Louizou to be named
"Never know with you lol"
2 hours ago
Uncle Wizardssleeve- Indigenous Elder-Freemason Hunter -He/Him replied to Anthony Mara's discussion Sam Louizou to be named
"Mate I wasn't having a go either brotha , I was just having a joke that all of us listen to bullshit on here every day . Without these tallywhackas and their inside scoops this joint would've been an NRL version of MySpace 15 years ago. "
2 hours ago
EA replied to Anthony Mara's discussion Sam Louizou to be named
"I never said he was joining Manly. Not sure where you got that from. I was just supporting Graham about the concerns of signing Da Silva. Unlike others, I do not change sides to suit the clubs decision. I still hold the same belief. I hope I am…"
3 hours ago
More…