He did more last night than Penisi has done in the last 2 years. Nanva and Samrani as our centre pairing would be good
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"Samrani has defence problems last night but coming back from injury to keep going the way he did impressive. He's always good in attack .if he's defence was OK in previous games he's a keeper"
"He has no speed. When is the last time he scored a runaway try? He could be a good meter eater in the wing, not a speedy one."
Replies
Penisini is a liability and the club needs to find a way to move him on. I would rather have samrani and nanva as our centres than have Penisini in the team.
They don't have to find a way. It appears he is not signed past this year, even though he has said in an interview some 6 months ago that he was resigned.
Samrani is a good tackler but some of us are overating his defensive reads. Go rewatch the first half and even Chester try.
100% but he's also a bloke that's started under 10 games at centre. Will has shown an inability to learn over 100+ games.
I think the biggest things for me other than adding more athleticism is Samrani has more of a footy IQ and be competes on everything . Will doesn't have that naturally in him. Ryles system seems to allow players to make the right decison wnd Will makes the wrong one over and over again . He can't play again if we're fair dinkum.
Yea Samrani will improve the more he plays there. I think he has a future whether it's a centre, wing or backrower is the question
Surely a priority re-signing ! Id leave him at centre for the remainder of this year at least!
Richie Pensini ruled out of nsw cup again. Petrus starting. Talagi and Miller on the bench
I no for sure we need an upgrade on the right wing and an upgrade at left centre at bare minimum.I looked at Chester and Perdue last night and they put the shits up our guys everytime they touched the ball.All of our centres struggle because of lack of lateral agility there all straight line players and not overly athletic.
Thats the key we need to find more Speed agility and Physicality across the park.It was a good game from our guys last night they fought to the end but if your looking at it from a long term proposition our roster is very limited as currently constructed.
Samrani is the most improved player in our club. Before his injury he was going well. I just love how he is an all in team player. Nothing selfish, thinks of the best person in the best position gets the ball ( Eg Papali ). His carries are strong and he is aware of players around his pre tackle as opposed to pushing balls in heavy contact becuase you havent thought about who was supporting you.
YES, definatel;y retain him. But I think JR will revert to Will.
Penisini is straight up terrible. Someone said he costs us games, which is completely true.
I dunno if I've ever seen a player butcher as many tries as Penisini fingers. Pack his bags, send him to perth with his mate Sean. Or PNG.
Plus he gets beaten by his opposing centre every single week and lets in at least 1 try or more every week.
every
single
game
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
of 4 Next