Judiciary From Eels vs Roosters

Parramatta five-eighth Dylan Brown is facing at least three weeks on the sidelines while centre Marata Niukore is facing a two-match ban after both were charged by the match review committee following Friday night's win over the Roosters.

Brown was hit with a grade three dangerous contact charge after sliding his knees into Roosters five-eighth Drew Hutchison, who was hospitalised with suspected fractured ribs and punctured lung.

 

Brown will miss three matches with an early guilty plea and risks a four-match suspension if he challenges the charge at the NRL judiciary.

Niukore will receive a two-match ban if he pleads guilty to a grade two careless high tackle on James Tedesco, and risks a three-match penalty if he loses at the judiciary.

Meanwhile Roosters prop Siosiua Taukeiaho is facing a $750 fine for a grade one careless high tackle on Parramatta's Keegan Hipgrave, with a discount for a seven-year incident-free record,

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • How the fuck was Siosiua Taukeiaho not charged for his tackle on Fergo. It was so careless. He picked Fergo's leg up and threw him head first into the group. Absolutely BS.

  • Brown should not challenge his ban. 3 weeks is fair. Niukore could possibly ask for a downgrade given he was already in a position to tackle. Niukore's arm was rapping around. However, because Tedesco fell, Niukore hit him in the head. 

    • What a load of crap it was totally accidental. Foul play Needs to be intentional is clearly wasn't it was an accident.

      • Agreed 

        Niukore was a total accident. The fact Paulo had him made Tedesco fall. He was basically on his knees when he fell into Niukore. How the fuck that is punishable is a joke.

        • That fucking happened against the dragons too... He always falls into tackles..

          • Yep. Tedesco's head was 3 feet from the ground when the Dragon's winger hit him. 

            • I found that call very annoying. Teddy always falls over. Some onus needs to be put on the ball carrier as well if they want to stamp out head knocks.

      • If your talking about D Brown. I 100% agree it was accidental. But it is simple. You can't slide in with your knees.

        I think Niukore got suspended because the NRL is really trying to make a statement about head high tackles due to concussion. Tedesco always falls over and in this case Paulo made Tedesco fall and Niukore couldn't do anything as he was already in the action of making a tackle. 

        • This reply was deleted.
          • This reply was deleted.
            • IDK how Siosiua Taukeiaho was not charged for his tackle on Fergo. It was so careless. He picked Fergo's leg up and threw him head first into the group. Absolutely BS. Brown's punishment was absolutely correct. However, the inconsistencies in the judiciary sysyem is evident as Taukeahio was not suspended. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Roy tannous posted a discussion
Grants been linked to knights and interesting,Grants open to moving to Newcastle.Just rumors at this stage but if it gets bigger and bigger.Knights can't afford him with ponga and brown on over a mill and others taking a lot of the cap.So what does…
5 seconds ago
Gucci replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels in talks to resign Jack Williams Luca Moretti and Sam tuivati
"The only issue I have is the head knocks because he puts himself in the strangest positions for a big man sometimes. But majority of his long term injuries were inflicted by other players in tackles for the past two seasons."
1 hour ago
Mathew Clarke replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels in talks to resign Jack Williams Luca Moretti and Sam tuivati
"Great news on all 3. I'm suprised many don't think Moretti is a good keep. He is just coming to age for Prop forwards (Mid 20's) and runs some great lines. I think he needs to have Williams show him the ropes and Luca, Teacum and Tuivaiti need to…"
1 hour ago
Yehez replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels in talks to resign Jack Williams Luca Moretti and Sam tuivati
"Slightly surprised at Moretti considering we have lots of forwards coming through. But at the same time, I have sensed him slightly going another level in our improved post origin performances.
All in all good news. Tuivati especially needs to be…"
1 hour ago
More…