In or out ?

13642780492?profile=RESIZE_710x

 

In any case there's no way the touchie can make that call on the run.  He should have left it for the video ref, who even with 8 cameras there's no doubt anyone could definitely say he was out.

 

Great fight back with a very depleted Parramatta team nonetheless, but this decision cost us the match.

For mine he can't be called out. The benefit of the doubt goes to the attacking side. Its inconclusive.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Clearly Out ....in any case a team that lets in 26 points in 33 min doesnt deserve to win 

    • Yep, game was lost with the soft first half. Woke up in the second half but just very sloppy defensively first stanza. 

      • So any team in the competition that's down at halftime has no right to come back and win 🤣🤣 and exactly which team do you support. 

        • blaming the ref aint changing the result ...our team is piss poor and still anchored at the bottom.  Plenty want to polish a turd with JR getting it right we can see the green shoots fuck that we are battling the spoon and the way we can attract players will be for years to come .  

    • Go to Specsavers Dude 😎 

  • Clearly in, but doesn't change the piss poor effort to half time. That's where we lost tonight.

    • Rubbish. Any team that's down at halftime and can come back and almost win is very good

      • So the effort in the first half wasn't piss poor?

        • Didn't say that did I ? Was the effort in the 2nd half piss poor? A game is 2 halves not 1. If the Eels ( or any team) can come back in the 2nd half and win (Eels should have they were robbed again) then that's a great effort especially considering Dragons were full strength and Eels were understrengthed 

  • It's a 50/50 live call but how the hell can the refs go all hawk eyed and pull up that while missing blatant forward passes, escorts and high shots from the dragons all game

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Joel K replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Paulo standoff with Eels
"650k is the same amount Trey Mooney is on. Would've been a handy signing but I heard we baulked on his asking price"
1 hour ago
Offside replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Nrl 360 says eels should target trell.
"I'd be ok with it as a centre and goal kicker.
Big risk but big reward "
2 hours ago
Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Nrl 360 says eels should target trell.
"Nope , not even for free.  More downside than upside . The baggage he brings with him wouid be like throwing fireworks in our dumpster fire. "
2 hours ago
Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Paulo standoff with Eels
"Paulo was already gone and we were quite happy for him to do so.  I was good with him at 600kish , I was even good with offering him a mutual second year .  But he's truly shown his colours now as a greedy prick who couldn't give two fucks about the…"
3 hours ago
More…