Hypothetical Question

If we were to add a prime Jarryd Hayne and a prime Semi Radradra to our current squad do you think we'd be a premiership threat?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

        • The front office didn't screw that, Kieran Foran did. Unless you're talking about the salary cap cheating, in which case, we wouldn't have signed all those players without it.

          • The front office screwed it because they got caught cheating that was the bigger issue.Foran unfortunately his body was at the end of it by the time he got to us and the mental state hurt him also.

            • Foran's body was fine. He played more NRL games after leaving Parra than he did before he got here.

              As for getting caught, that's the risk every club takes when they fuck around with 'arms length' TPAs. The alternative is mediocrity.

              • No it wasn't he was used up and he fell off the cliff because of it.Us Dogs GC Warriors I mean he didn't play a full season because of his body.It gave up the ghost bigtime.

                 

          • Pou is right Coryn....Fos was the fcuk up, no one else....maybe BA as he knew him well enough to know he had problems.

            • Foran played 162 NRL games AFTER HE LEFT THE EELS. Add that to the 147 he played in his first stint at Manly and the 9 games he played for us, Foran played over 300 NRL games. Hardly a player with "problems". Most likely is that he got the fuck out of Parra to avoid getting sanctioned for signing dodgy TPAs. His form was pretty good for us.

            • When do you think the last time Foran played a full nrl season Pops without injury ? Vs how many seasons he had and playing those 300 games.Foran I agree had issues off the park but his body was shot when he got to us just having a look back at his manly injury history the writing was on the wall for the mentioned drop off to happen health wise.

              http://www.racingandsports.com.au/amp/news/sports/other/2019-11-13/...

              • Coryn, don't miss my point, it wasn't a front office fcukup in the context you said. Yes Foz had injuries.

                All the other aspects are fair enough, politely no one has mentioned his mental state at the time, probably an issue that really caused his rejection. Watmough was the one at this time that had an irrecoverable injury, although there was a defence that indicated BA still wanted him for other purposes.....subjectively.

  • No because we are still parramatta and we would fuck it up somehow 

  • Yes, in today's rules Hayne and Semi would be unstoppable with Moses, Iongi, Addo Carr. But our forwards and Centre will let us down in much bigger games.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Hell On Eels replied to Adam Hayne's discussion Will Penisini Gone
"Randy, your wit and humour is elite. You're obviously highly intelligent and add a lot to this site. No doubts about that.  
 "
34 seconds ago
Randy Handlinger replied to Adam Hayne's discussion Will Penisini Gone
"Guy who made the word "Scapegoating" the official 1EE catchphrase informs me that I am tedious...roger that.
...,and yeah, I think I can be funny. I know I miss more than I hit, it's the nature of the beast, but I am one of the few posters left who…"
4 minutes ago
Hell On Eels replied to Adam Hayne's discussion Will Penisini Gone
"Randy, I don’t make fun of medical conditions, joke about doxxing people, or use private conversations as white-anting jabs at moderation. You have. Please stop and reflect on that behaviour.
That said, if some posters genuinely feel attacked by me…"
8 minutes ago
Prof. Daz replied to Adam Hayne's discussion Will Penisini Gone
"Randy, you spliced together something. I said with something NOS said, so there is nothing to answer, unless you want NOS and I to fuse into one?
You still think your attributions are funny but they're not only arr they just tedious, they permit you…"
13 minutes ago
More…