Replies

    • Yea he has played some 5/8. But FB is easily his best spot

      • Yes he was impressive and now join's the same queue/crew as Joash Pappalii lining up behind the first choice 5/8 and the fullback.

        I think his key issue will be his physique, if he becomes more solid, i think he could be a good centre, just not built like one yet, but his anticipation to follow the play looks outstanding, great hands....don't know about defence and outright speed. It would  be brilliant to see us develop a Casy McLean.

        Good players like this kid develop as wingers/fullbacks and if no openings appear 5/8 to centre.

        How tough is he EA, I have heard that on some occasions, he has let you down.

        • Your Casey Mclean/Makisini is Lorima Seuseu in HM. 16 this year and you can just tell with him the sky is the limit. Centre/Fullback also in the warratahs accademy.

          Defense is Twiddle weakness. 

  • Sam Moa take a bow I loved our physicality and defensive contact the whole game.

    All but a TDS poor defensive read we hold the sharks to zip.

    13/15 with the ball 2 handling errors and the above is now the benchmark it's exactly the type of stats you build your side around and take some confidence down to Melbourne.This has to be the floor if we want consistency.

    We now have depth within the club which is great to see.Tuivaiti looks like he's grown this off season and looks like he could really adds some impetus in the middle of the park.In saying that though I saw it again when he gets tired he'll get targeted like he did tonight missed on the repeated effort.Seen this before.

    TDS I don't know man you haven't got me convinced yet.

    The big units coming on all added something in attack and defense I thought as above there's definitely depth and if they stay on track we could have a devastating pack in a year or 3.

    Defensive effort can't be questioned tonight for the most part I loved the inside pressure and the first up contact which really secures the edges love it.

    Errors were to a minimum again this performance has to be our floor not our ceiling.

    Great first hit out it leaves you wanting to see more.

    • I agree. TDS is still young but for me Smith is the better player and the one I rather keep

      • We have to see what Ryles sees. He agreed to giving him a deal 2 years longer than Smith. He knew what he had with Smith when signing Da Silva, wasn't like Smith all of a sudden performed after Da Silva was signed. So Ryles sees something and perhaps is banking on Da Silva being the future. But if by early 2027 Da Silva hasn't got it, Smith is still here.

    • Coryn, that is not our floor

    • I thought the defensive effort right though the game was pretty Dam good 

    • Coryn, didn't you say you could tell by the first trial last year we wouldn't be ready for Round 1? Do you feel different now?
      Sorry if i misquoted you.

      • More positive this year I didn't too much care for the score but I can see more connection defensively I can see inside pressure.I can see a lower error count I can see more physicality from our middles with and without the ball.I can also see with time there's more integration of how comfortable players are within the setup both FG and development they all look well entrenched.

        Thats a good thing as when players get injured when we talk next man up there shouldn't be too many issues slotting right in.Make no mistake Melbourne will be tough down there but I think we are light years ahead of where we were last year purely because we are still using the pill and not making any errors.So yes I want to see more and if we can continue to improve I don't see why with our strongest line up we can't play finals footy this year.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

EA replied to Poppa's discussion The Unicorns Strike Back
"No idea. Renzo is absolutely carving up nsw cup right now"
48 seconds ago
EA replied to Poppa's discussion The Unicorns Strike Back
"Sternum "
1 minute ago
EA replied to Poppa's discussion The Unicorns Strike Back
"Ohk"
1 minute ago
Prof. Daz replied to Poppa's discussion The Unicorns Strike Back
"Their first contact was the best we have seen in 2026. No coincidence they mostly kept the Dogs to their own half. Big lesson right there. 
I also thought Pryke was an effective tackle machine, Maetele hit hard, and Williams-Guymer and Paulo were…"
2 minutes ago
More…