End of Season rule changes

 

The NRL in the past has trialed rule changes at the end of the season for teams playing in dead rubbers.

With Melbourne out of contention and a few more to join them in a month or so, they should look at trialling some innovative ideas.

 

1.       5 minute sin bin. Bring it back and make it expire when a try is scored.

2.       Replacements for send offs. Maybe then the refs will start using it more often.

3.       Unlimted bench.... Every team carries an 18th man. I don’t see the problem with carrying 4 primary interchange players and carrying 1,2 or 100 under21’s players (that have played the 21’s match that day) on the extended bench to be used at the discretion of the coach. This doesn’t benefit any team as you still only get 10 interchanges. But you have the benefit of blooding youngsters if  games are won/lost  with 20 mins to go or you get too many injuries.... the exposure can only help.

And some far left field suggestions - almost Mark GeyeresqueJ

Automatic 2 point conversion for any try scored under the posts or 5m either side.

Line drop outs to be taken from the 20m line under all circumstances in order to encourage tries over repeat sets.

5 points for a try through the hands. 4 points for a try via a kick.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I like the idea of the 5 minute Sin-Bin and the Unlimited bench. You can't replace a Send-off that means you still have 13 men on the field giving the opposition no reward. Automatic 2 points? I remember seeing a match between Roosters and cant remember who but SKD took a goal attempt in line with the right post and missed, so it's not always an automatic 2 points. By having the drop-out from the 20m line is stupid (I'm not saying you are I just think that is stupid) because big kickers e.g. Hayne,Campese,Lockyer,Inu might be able to kick the ball into the oppositions in-goal and force a drop-out. The 5 point try and 4 point try is useless, I thought people wanted to see the athleticism of wingers and centers jumping for the ball e.g Folau,Inu,Inglis,Idris, not just using their strength to score tries.
    • Some interesting ideas there. One rule change I'd like to see is at scrums which are non existent anyway, one of the refs stays at the scrum and gives a 10 count before players can leave creating backs on backs more chances more skill more risk and set play options, would be awesome
    • My thinking is that the league is not creating enough footballers and only athletes.... Evidence of this the fact we are so skinny on 6 and 7's these days... We can't find one and Canberra for eg are using Adam Mog. Incentives for passing tries over kicking triesyou would think would force clubs to develop halves with more than just kicking skills
  • I would like the rules surrounding a potential draw to change.

    If a game is tied up at full time on equal points, then each team gets 1 point and the additional point is played for over 2 ten minute halves. A team, only claims victory if they can better the oppostion by 3 points or more ....this rules out a kickathon or a soft penalty deciding the result.

    If the teams can't better their opponent by 3 points (this gives incentive for teams to go for a try) or more in this ) then each team gets 1 point.

    If a team scores 3 or more points better than the opposition at the end they get 2 points while the loser keeps their 1 point.

    This aims to give each team and fans credit for a draw, lessens ref's mistakes deciding the game and stops the field goal kickathon....any thoughts?
    • so they have just played 80 minutes and you expect them to play another 20?
  • I like that idea, maybe not 10 seconds though, 5 would be maximum
  • I am taking it that you want to see young players getting exposure to 1st grade YDIDISAYIDO.

    Sin bin and send offs cannot be changed otherwise players will exploit the soft approach by refs.

    Scrums to be abolished completely with a play the ball instead.

    Minimum 20 minutes on the field for any player with unlimited interchange.

    Get rid of golden point - after 80 mins if game tied - then guess what? It's a draw. 1 point each.

    when run on team announced the kicker is also named. Elected kicker cannot take kicks in front or inside 5M either side of posts. Good exposure for young blokes.
    • "I am taking it that you want to see young players getting exposure to 1st grade YDIDISAYIDO" given that we no longer have a strong reseerve grade comp then why not. They did it in the old days.

      "Sin bin and send offs cannot be changed otherwise players will exploit the soft approach by refs".... can't agree... our game is really clean and the league in general is trigger happy. The only difference you will see IMO is that the refs will send more players off... they are too scared to do it now because it will cost a team the game 90% of the time.

      Agree about the draw.. I never had a problem with 1 point each
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst posted a discussion
https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1C4PtwkE1C/?mibextid=wwXIfrOn his way home from an interstate trip, Josh Addo-Carr got a call that compelled him to stop and turn back. It was a call about a boy named Lachie, battling a brain tumour and there was…
1 hour ago
Tad replied to Eels2025's discussion Jason Ryles... Report so far
"Patriarchy will it continue or have we had enough 
https://youtube.com/shorts/5sV4rw1cMpA?si=GxHa1B-XYbH_CkJf"
2 hours ago
Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Tallyn Debut
"650k???
For that money, he better be starting."
3 hours ago
EA replied to Anthony Mara's discussion Sam Louizou to be named
"Never know with you lol"
5 hours ago
More…