Replies

  • I'm interested to see how Ilongi handles5/8 for Tonga this weekend. You never know, then I would be going all out for Bula.

  • This deal is hot garbage and no amount of gas lighting will convince me wasting cap space on a Broncos player is good sense buy another prop or someone long term to help the team instead 

    • Signing a bloke for 2026 isn't going to stop us signing anyone long term. He will be off the books in 2027.

  • If JR uses Pezet like he used Dylbags in 2025 then I'm kinda ok with it. 
    Remember the 'future is now' line as Brown was sat on the sideline to give Joash some FG experience? Surely Pezet will be used similarly to give our other young halves access to FG later in the season. That would be a positive use of his limited time here. 
    But if Pezet has a lock on the 6 jersey for a full season then it's a pointless move. We'll be in the exact same spot this time next year. 
    I have to trust JR here. Even though I don't love this signing at all. 

    • I suspect Ryles is more pragmatic than some of us punters. Winning matters. Pezet helps that cause in his mind and is a stop gap.

      Meanwhile, we're outraged, calling him a liar for betraying some badge of noble ideals, seeing the one-year deal as a breach of rigid ideology. And now his Kaizen is also bullsheet to some. Easy to do sitting on the sidelines. Yet, we're naive enough to want to eat our cake too. And will judge him on winning anyway.

      Us wanting our cake and eating it too isn’t groundbreaking. We call the club cheap dopes for getting Pezet cheap, and dumb, desperate dopes when we pay overs.

      Somehow we assume Ryles has this “he won’t play Dylan because he isn’t committed” mindset, and we celebrated how Ryles didn’t play Dylan for most of the year. Bollocks. Dylan played 19 from 24 games. That’s most of the year. Ryles probably knew the season was a lost cause, so was more willing to toy with project Papali’i at six and use Dylan wherever he needed.

      Dylan was also committed enough to stay when the door was open for a mid-year transfer out. Big deal. Ryles also knows pressure will mount fast if the team doesn’t improve next year.

      For me, that’s a good sign. Because upholding rigid ideologies without the ability to bend like grass when the wind blows can bring down a coach whose job is to win on the scoreboard, not just the ideology game.

      Ryles seized on this Pezet opportunity like he did on Fox and Walker. Many questioned those too. Oh, Fox is over the hill, bad for culture. Oh, Walker is old and ordinary, won’t bring much. We wondered about Williams. And why he persisted with Kautoga. Then there was the backlash over Gutho and RCG, our best last year. He let them go without much hesitation. But sure, he’ll make mistakes on R&R. Guaranteed.

      BA’s weakness was his failure to adapt quickly enough to his limited, rigid strategies. It’s about making short-term decisions that help win, over long-term principles that only serve a framework. I’m glad Ryles isn’t that way. He has strong principles about doing right by the club and staying aligned with the GM and CEO. And not just building his own castles. They’re united now, which wasn’t the case with BA.

      Ryles has a balance of principles, practicality and adaptability. He’s also building resilient systems with interchangeable parts for the club’s long-term health. Pezet is just a better short-term fill-in for now, until he finds the missing part. Hopefully that’s in-house and some rookies will be more ready than right now. If not, Ryles will find another way.

      • For the most part HOE punters are willing to give Ryles the benefit of the doubt.

        As a fan there seems to be problems with his messaging with the Pezet situation.

        Internaly it mightn't be a problem and the players are on board but the fans can see a little hypocrisy here.

        If you want a successful club it pays to have the administration, sponsors, players , former players and fans all pulling in the same direction.

        Ive had a fair bit to do with Wayne Bennett from an early age and he always banged on about developing the man , it was more important then the footballer it formed the basis of his footballing philosophy.

        He wanted to develop men with the right ethos who's family and community would be proud .

        Players bought in then he dumped his family like a school port at the start of kindergarten and left with a side piece.

        Plenty of people who believed his message all those years are filthy on him now ,he was full of shit.

        Ask Tallis privately what he thinks of Wayne.

        Interestingly Bennet hasn't had the same success since.Hmmm

        My point is when you talk about culture , believing in the jumper you can't just speak it you have to live it through every decision you make as a coach and a person because that's what you've signed up for.

        Once that message starts to be questioned by those stakeholders above your in trouble.

        The Eels PR team has to work overtime here because the fan base is a little miffed, a couple of quality signings would quite that noise down but a lot of people will be watching Ryles and co a lot more closely from here out.

        Fans would have accepted this better if the club was honest from the outset rather then arse cover over another missed recruit.

        Lends into the theory that people are more worried about their own future job prospects then that of the club and that only ends badly.

        Hopefully any news about the Eels the rest of the off season is a lot more positive.

         

        • Insightful comment Bup.I hadn't properly connected those dots

          I have some first-person stories re wayne's family that would utterly prevent me buying into Wayne's "ethos"

  • Parra fans have every right to be pissed over this actual deal no matter how much Braiths mates try tell us otherwise!
    Any case, hope  he fits straight into his 6 role and Moses and him gel and that he can sit back and let Moses be the boss. Hope this doesn't work out as wrong as dogs Galvin buy did , a dead set 6 trying hard to be a leading 7 viseversa ha! funny that master coach Bellamy never thought of slipping him in at 6...

    🤞Parra have got this right and the deal very much to suit the player was very very cheap!

    Pezet don't let our JR down ! Lots of pressure on all in this deal, Im sure crowd will come after you if you do 🫤

  • They can say all they want but in my opinion it's a really dumb idea. Actually stupid idea. I don't see the point in having a player on a 'speed bump' contract! It's not going to benefit Joash Papali or the Eels team as a whole. They get used to playing together with Pezet for a season then he's off to the broncos 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Randy Handlinger replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion EELS FANS STOP WHINGING
"Insightful comment Bup.I hadn't properly connected those dots
I have some first-person stories re wayne's family that would utterly prevent me buying into Wayne's "ethos""
16 minutes ago
Bourbon Man replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion EELS FANS STOP WHINGING
"Now, why would Braith say that I wonder?
Could it be because it's better optics for his client for it to appear clubs are fighting over his him as opposed to what is widely being reported that a club that missed the 8 wasn't interested in his 'star'…"
35 minutes ago
LB replied to Eli Stephens's discussion NAS
"I do not mind it depending on years of course. If it can be 1-2 years then great. He has a point to prove."
48 minutes ago
fishbulb replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion EELS FANS STOP WHINGING
"Agree,the club needs to be looking at improving that aspect of operations. At the very least a refresh - i think MON has been in the role too long for a start."
54 minutes ago
More…