As i said EA, if he is better than what we "can get" and better than "what we have", then the equation and response is simple.
Your response is more to does it block a pathway for a development player? That balance still exists if adopting the equation.....call it a "quantum" response, you will never know the answer until you run it.
Just checked the calendar to see if it was April 1. Garner is passed his best and not what is needed for now or the future. MON got to do a lot better. Sounds like a desperate move. Rather look at some younger players and try them. Waste of salary cap
Though the report is mixed as it says we were keen but is off to a rival as they offered a 3 year deal. Wouldn't they say Parra offered a 3 year deal?
Now let's say we didn't get him, bit rough there lol but hey he took 3 year deal good on him, if we did miss him it is down to not offering a 3 year deal which I feel we shouldn't have.
"Amazing that a team leading the comp is still buying players before June 30 and yet, at the Eels, we've released almost half a squad and still cant sign a player, even if that player wanted to pay us to play.
What a mess we are."
"I could see it happening, they haven't had a full team since 2022 just like us. Add Murray, Graham, Fifita and a healthy Cody walker and they have a good chance"
"Exactly and I am glad someone else said it. The hypocrisy of some of these decisions is just laughable and it can only come down to saving money in the cap. Thus far what have we spent it on and do we have better replacements? BTW, where are we on…"
Replies
As i said EA, if he is better than what we "can get" and better than "what we have", then the equation and response is simple.
Your response is more to does it block a pathway for a development player? That balance still exists if adopting the equation.....call it a "quantum" response, you will never know the answer until you run it.
I don't mind Gardner. Was very good at tigers. I think our game will suit him. Hopefully coming now. I prefer on the edge.
Just checked the calendar to see if it was April 1. Garner is passed his best and not what is needed for now or the future. MON got to do a lot better. Sounds like a desperate move. Rather look at some younger players and try them. Waste of salary cap
If you had to check your calendar to see if it was April 1 or not, it sort of rules out your opinion?
If you have trouble with dates, friend up with Arnie and Camel Toe (CE).....they are always out of date.
If you are gonna sign players they either need to be:
A).better than what you have/had, or
B) are young and have potential
Garner is neither.
Dear god no.
What's the point of getting rid of players who are past their best only to replace them with players who are past their best.
This club is a circus run by a bunch of fucking clowns.
I agree they never fucking learn do they. Mark o neil needs to fuck off to Mcdonalds.
If that ass clown got a job at Macca's, I sure as hell wouldn't eat from that store.
Agree for a stop gap measure until we have our Juniors ready or some good calibre back rower comes along.
He is much better runner than Taulagi and Samrani.
Though the report is mixed as it says we were keen but is off to a rival as they offered a 3 year deal. Wouldn't they say Parra offered a 3 year deal?
Now let's say we didn't get him, bit rough there lol but hey he took 3 year deal good on him, if we did miss him it is down to not offering a 3 year deal which I feel we shouldn't have.
If not us, could be Dragons or Manly.