With Kelly named in the squad and a player who has no pace which is needed out of dummy half and also not noted as a solid defender another requirement if defending in the middle, BA has hinted at rotating the position with J Paulo but that poses the question where does he hide Kelly in defence when Paulo is at 9? Is Kelly simple benched? Has Paulo learnt to pass off the ground in the last week?

I have still not worked out how the defensive line would look but I can see Sandow playing some 9 during the game early in attacking sets to catch the big Cowboy off-side leaving Kelly "mr structured" to simply catch and pass early in the set.

What a bloody dilemma trying to replace Peatsy my approach feels like the Money Ball movie....using 3 players in the attempt to replicate 1.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I'm looking forward to Kelly at 9.
    He has a football brain and whilst his defence is not really up to the role his skill set will hopefully benefit us.
    Did he play a bit of 9 in a game verse the panthers when he first joined? I believe he and Paulo worked well together.
  • Kelly will do his Job. He has a good football brain. Everyone relax. We will beat the cowboys 26-14. Hayne will be mom. Then i will kick on at kicks for $1 drinks, then back up for work in the morning!
    • All sounds good Craig and I will throw some money on the pick the score, unfortunately kicks done and dusted a long time ago now but I had more than my fair share of $1 drinks back in the day. Tell me where you can go out these days with $30 in the wallet and need to be carried out and tried every spirit available?

    • Yes they were the days. How good was it.
    • Bert, in answer to your question, my next door Macedonian neighbour's house. FMD they have some strong spirits...
  • This reply was deleted.
    • Well there is a "magic bullet" on the home shopping channel but it is a juicer unfortunately.

  • Cowboys don't play very good in Sydney, they have a bad record.
    So we have a chance of winning
  • His speed is between the ears, like no other as a dummy half. Engages the markers in every play and shifts the ball to the correct side every time. Luke Kelly's speed would be equal to Smiths not sure about any other comparisons.

  • If you think about it dummy half should suit Paulo's crab-like sideways running as we see the good dummy halves Farah, Smith, Ennis etc do it all the time with great affect passing back on the inside.

  • The games gunna be won down the middle, if we can prevent the cowboys forwards from getting on a role, Thurston can be contained. If we do this, and limit our errors we can go a long way in our comp. as we have shown over this year, we can score points from pretty much anywhere, especially with the likes of Hayne semi and Sio.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Muttman replied to Offside's discussion Samrani vs Penisini
"Even the Knights have 2 Origin Centres these days. (And an Origin FB and the Kiwi 5/8). "
4 hours ago
EA replied to Offside's discussion Samrani vs Penisini
"I remember watching him in nsw cup. He was at left centre with Naiduki on the wing. I remember every week saying he should make his nrl debut. He was such a good defender at 18/19 years old. I would argue since then that his attacking threat has…"
4 hours ago
DYNASTY.LOADING replied to Pato's discussion Xerri
"Michael, you are dumb. Doesn't mean you are a bad bloke.
The whole game of managing a roster is value for money. Will Penisni gets paid the same as the great Centres in the game and he isn't one. Move him on, it's not harder than that. Hos brother…"
5 hours ago
Yehez replied to Offside's discussion Samrani vs Penisini
"He did and he more importantly has this tendency to switch off and look despondent and defeated and his effort goes down by 30 %. 
I made my piece that he might not reach the potential we hoped of him becoming an origin level back, which he was…"
5 hours ago
More…