Double Standards

Cleary's ankle broken in preliminary final, with foul play (hip drop tackle). Stretchered off. Ref sends the Knight off because of extreme risk/damage.

Simmonson's ankle broken in Round 5, with foul play (mid air tackle). Stretchered off. Ref sends the Tiger to the sin bin for 10 mins, after telling bunker "it looks bad". 

Luckily there is not a double standard where some teams are take care of and others have to fend for themselves. Sarcasm emoji's galore. 

Double standard or the new standard?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

        • Mallee you do realise it was not the same leg....don't you?

          PS I suggest the staff at Penrith do not tell any Cleary what to do......

    • It was not the injured foot. His injury befire this game was his right foot. He has now broken his left foot.

      • All Footloose references are appropriate. 

      • Yes but IF the Penrith coaching staff used some common sense they shouldn't have played him period! Putting a player at further risk by sending him into an important game with a 'broken right foot' is just sheer incompetence and stupidity. His health is more important than playing in a grand final and it's not as if he hasn't won before.

  • Penalties and sanctions always based  on  the players , forwards get done for head highs and backs dont

    but anyway it's karma (still feel sorry for Cleary) as Penrith downplayed it when they did it to our player doe season ending 

    the nrl and coaches reap what they sow and today was the result , there is no excuse for this tackle , never existed before 

  • Blaize T injury about 2m before he is tackled. Obviously send Ponga off. 

    New standard

    • Forget Talagi for 2027, Achilles tear it seems. Not back til mid year 2027.

      • Given his lengthy recovery into next year, poses an interesting conumdrum for Penrith. How do they move him on for 2027 to make way for Jett Cleary and some cap space to retain his big brother.

        The repercussions from those 2 injuries today are HUGE.

  • Knights 16-0 in second half fo win when down 12 to 13 players is called sweet justice for the double standards 

    • Agreed

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Poppa replied to Prof. Daz's discussion Double Standards
"Mallee you do realise it was not the same leg....don't you?
PS I suggest the staff at Penrith do not tell any Cleary what to do......"
1 minute ago
shane replied to Parra-all-the-way's discussion moses to be 7 in world up now?
"walters a QLDer and loves QLDers, Walker and Munster will be the halves with Tedesco or Walsh fullback"
5 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Prof. Daz's discussion Double Standards
"That's subjudice"
6 minutes ago
Phil Mann replied to Prof. Daz's discussion Double Standards
"Surely the seriousness is assessed at the judiciary when the player fronts, not from a diagnosis made by a ref or bunker official.  "
11 minutes ago
More…