Replies

    • Apparently we don't need anyone yes we do he shits on what we have! 

      • 🧌 🧌 

      • Dom young shits on lomax? Such a bad troll

  • Yes please make it happen and yes we do need 2 front rowers and 1 2rd rower we got the money so go hard get them or we will struggle again 

  • Don't need him, he's so average and to top it off an a-grade Wanker. The roosters don't let players go early without a serious issue

    • Yet they signed him in the first place? The gloss has certainly come off the Roosters R&R team. Brandon Smith, Chad Townsend and now Dominic Young... 

      • Agree but he did look promising a few years ago. Hindsight is a beautiful thing

  • Young unfortunately is not a consistant first grader. If he can't find form on the end of the Roosters system then we would have no hope of turning him around.

    A 76% tackle efficiency this year, 78% last year, 81% year before and 79% before that. Not a very good defensive proposition. 

    5 years in the NRL with a 41% win ratio when he plays.

    I think I'd rather stick with Lomax and Addo Carr, get rid of Penisni and Russell and go all in on signing Cobbo or Staggs who are both off contract.

     

     

    • Penisini is fine on the right.

      • Sorry Clintorian, but he just isn't. The amount of trys he blows just through not being in position or not being able to see the play required is staggering. It goes unnoticed way too much. 

        'You can pick up small things on the TV, like not setting a winger up, no draw and pass options, running lateral and taking the wingers space, not in position to back up a runner or the pace to support a break. Lying in the ruck more times then not after being involved in a tackle, having a low 80% tackle efficiency, struggling to provide try assists. The list goes on. The Penisni highlight reel would not be very bright. He has had 3 or 4 years, 80 odd games, he should be really showing his talent now, but it seems like he hasn't improved an inch in the last 3 years. 

        He may be a fan favourite, but honestly he is a budget option centre and performs to that standard. I don't think he would have too many man of the match awards or been credited with too many Dally M points for that matter in his career. To be competitive at NRL level a team needs their centre to be a strike weapon. I don't think Penisni is that.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

The Badger replied to Parra fan on The Hill's discussion Can we make the 8?
"Mathematically ...yes! 
In reality ...maybe, but unlikely.
We need to get and keep our best team on the park to have any chance. The next month will tell us if we are a chance. "
3 minutes ago
SuperEel 22 replied to SuperEel 22's discussion Your questions for the club and feedback for the Supporters Group Alliance
"Our remit is mainly fan and member engagement along with community outreach. We do get an opportunity to ask about football operations and Mark is there and very open to questions, we just don't have input if that makes sense. For example, we asked…"
3 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Ryles is doing fine with a half-priced roster
"Now if Elements of Management, in particular whomever is negotiating and closing contracts of real talented players could be improved.
Perhaps we could move the club to be competitive on the ladder, and give Ryles real talent / skill and pace to be…"
3 minutes ago
GM replied to Parra fan on The Hill's discussion Can we make the 8?
"GF is unicorn stuff, getting close to the 8 would be huge considering the rebuild "
6 minutes ago
More…