DOES PARRAMATTA ACTUALLY NEED GALVIN?

I actually hope Parramatta don't get Galvin as what he will cost does not match the talent he will bring.

 

Between Longi and Papalia we have a 6 and a 1 who will take far less money out of the cap and  if I had to choose between Galvin as a player and Longi as player id take Longi 100% , this kid is all class in everything he does.

 

Galvin has proved zero and to pay a kid 700k + who has done zero is a huge risk because he could easily become another Dylan Brown , Parramatta need to stop paying big dollars for potential because as a club we have had no luck in this department. We need at least one top shelf centre and a few top shelf to medium shelf forwards and not a kid who has proven very little . 

 

History has shown for decades that Parramatta do not have much luck when it comes to paying big money for players from others clubs , Parramatta have  succees when they develop their own juniors or buy good young players from others clubs on the cheap end develop them. 

 

Galvin is a 400k player at best and not a cent more , Parramatta need to get back to what has given them success in the past and paying big money for purely potential has failed most of the time for Parramatta .

 

 

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • He's going to be the best player in the game one day. He's worth the money they are talking about if it's a longer term deal. But that's just my opinion. 

  • If we get him good but hopefully at the right price if not then no big loss IMO.   He can be this quazi 6/7 at the dogs with burton.  We can continue our development within.   In any case our 1.7.9 are far better then the dogs.     I agree the dogs will be smoked at the end of season in the big games like N QLD in 2022

  • I hope we don't get him. To be honest I think he is over rated. Think he is a sooky little bitch.

     

  • Some good points you've raised but not all 100% accurate. The Eels have purchased some good players over the years and have also produced some good juniors as well. The positive thing about Galvin is he's young and if information is correct he wants to play for the Eels! If he decides to go with the Bulldogs then so be it but I think he's better suited for the Eels as what Ryles is doing is extremely positive and will produce great results. There is no reason why Galvin, Iongi and Papalli can't all be in the same 17 moving forward. Galvin will be a great fit at the Eels more than at the Bulldogs. I can't see him being happy at the Bulldogs 

  • I think he the player we been waiting and looking and need i hope we get him but you are wright he not worth that but that what he wants that what he gets and i hope it from us

  • Papali is a talent and hope we find a fit for him in the future. Would he make a six, I couldn't say at this point in time. 14 maybe.

  •  

     1 major difference between Galvin and Brown is, apparently Galvin is a footy fanatic. I've heard he watches and studies most games.  I heard an interview with Brown a few years ago and he said that he never watches rugby league other than in video sessions at training. The players that spend their time studying the game are the ones that strive to improve their own game, the others are happy to just plod along.

     Going by the small sample size I've seen of Galvin, with the right coaching and without serious injuries I think he will become one of the best players in the game. His skill level combined with his confidence and work ethics (from what has been reported) makes me confident Galvin will become great. Only time will tell. 

  • Remember what Moses did too, he returned back home from the tigers. Imagine Galvin coming back and learning from Moses whilst increasing his skill. 

  •  

    Galvin is a very different player. At 19, he is in the class of Cleary & Katoa at similar ages, imo, and they’re more generational than common. 
     
    He hasn’t achieved a lot yet, as no 19 year old players have, but elite clubs in any sport identify talent, personality, cognitive ability, cultural fit etc very early in careers & invest in those players. If you want to pay on ‘achievement’, you’re paying a lot more & there are still no guarantees.
     
    You only have to look at the Tigers, who have a 1.2m 4 x Premiership winner, who has been completely outshone by a 19 year old rookie because the systems around him have changed - and not purely in attack but in the 1%ers & tough work that few young halves have the confidence for at 19.
     
    The difference with Galvin is (from all reports) his mindset. The kid lives & breathes footy, and the fact he’s giving up huge money for development is a great sign. 
     
    Moses won’t last forever, and has his injury concerns, Galvin is insurance there also because he looks every bit capable of taking the reins - something we don’t feel DB could do.
     
    1. Iongi 6. Galvin 7. Moses 9. Smith.
     
    In a few years that spine is capable of competing for premierships & 3 of them have 10+ year careers possibly ahead. 
     
    The Storm & Panthers have shown to go that extra step, you need an elite spine & you develop / purchase the hard workers around it - as JR is already doing in Williams, Walker etc
     
    We want players who are passionate about the Eels, who love our club (not just being first grade players) and we have one of the best young players in the game, who just happens to be an Eels fan, and just happens to play the position we are losing a very good player in. 
     
    Very rare any club, let alone the Eels, get an opportunity like this & could define the next 5-10 years. If we don’t land Galvin, considering his Eels roots & Moses, it would show we still can’t compete for the signatures of in demand players despite advantages & that would be concerning. 
     
    Just opinion though, and good blog Frankie.
    • 100.

      Like you mention when one of the smartest in the game is saying the team who lands this guy has the potential to win multiple premierships what do our devoted do sit on the fence and get the inferior player because he's cheaper oh dear.This is no disrespect to Sandon Smith either there just different players on different trajectories.Galvin potentially at 23 could be one of the best in the game.

      Then we curse our front office for not having a good crack at him.Im with you NoS everything you've said if we can land this kid it definitely keeps the arrow firmly pointed in the right direction.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER's discussion Fletcher Baker
"Someone that's nasty"
37 minutes ago
LB replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Wishart and Sua need to leave storm.
"As you say admittedly not to great success, Hayne being the prime example there out of them who failed at 6. Munster was an established first grader as was Campbell and Wighton when they moved. Brimson went between both 1 and 6 in juniors and Inglis…"
3 hours ago
Frank The Tank replied to CarloEEL2's discussion Pre match interview w Ryles
"Yeah watched it earlier this evening. I like how he carries himself now 
He's seems pretty confident and has settled into this role nicely. He came across as quietly confident about tomorrows result and seemed excited about the prospect of the boys…"
4 hours ago
Parra-all-the-way replied to CarloEEL2's discussion Pre match interview w Ryles
"I like the way he talks more and more. I think I'm starting to buy into it all. Maybe just maybe I'm starting to believe ryles might get us to the holy grail. 
We play like we did v panthers, we give the dogs are good shot. "
5 hours ago
More…