Burgess only gets 1 week

I can't beleive he only got 1 week and that there has not been any sort of uproar from the media.

 

It was an very ugly incident and deserved 4 weeks.... just can't mess with necks in our game.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • It was ugly, true, but it was after all his first charge, and there has been a lot worse. I think 1 week is probably about right.

    From what I have read, he had never been charged in the UK either so it does seem like it was a one-off. 4 weeks would of been too harsh IMO.

    Maybe im just a bit biased, I like the guy. He seems very down to earth, easy going, and extremely tough on the field. He is aggressive and it's pleasure seeing him play.

    4 weeks, specially in this time of the year would of received a big uproar from the media, but 1 week is about right IMO.
  • one week is enough for souths to get another loss and hep parra move ahead of them.
  • well hayne got of with a headbutt so i cant complain
  • It did look very ugly YDIDISAYIDO but there was also a lot of momentum in that tackle.
    Burgess also did not appear to deliberately drive him into the ground but with the combination of momentum and body positioning he came down on top of the player.

    If there had of been any indication otherwise I think the judiciary would have given him longer. Much longer
  • truthfully i thought their was nothing in it, have seen worse things not get picked up and get off. its only that barba stayed down.
  • Rugby league is a body contact sport and head high tackles in particular I can live with because its easy for fatigue to settle in.... timing etc to be off.

    Howwever, what Burgess did was purely idiotioc. He simply renched Barba's neck via his chin.... his action was not consistant with "working a player" or carrying out a tackle. It was a deliberate act to cause the other player some discomfort... definately a brain snap BUT... how much further would Burgess have to go to cause serious injury.... another 1/2 a cm perhaps.

    It was very very very stupid. I am sure he was not far off causing a very serious injury.
  • 4 weeks... are you serious?? 1 week was fair for a 1st time offender.
  • OOPS - commented on a different play altogether.
    Damm - old age and cold weather don't mix.

    Yeah the neck snapper should have got a lot more.
    Sorry guys
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Tad replied to Eels2025's discussion Jason Ryles... Report so far
"The other issue I have with technology is how it is affecting our interpersonal communication with addiction to those devices and taking us away from nature."
2 minutes ago
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER replied to ParraEels's discussion Cleary isn't an Origin player
"Lol i only watch first 20 mins i knew it was game set match"
5 minutes ago
Tad replied to Eels2025's discussion Jason Ryles... Report so far
"The two issues I have with AI HOE are who is spending the billion dollars to own AI and their motives, and the ability for AI to eventually (if not already now) develop independently from human inputs."
6 minutes ago
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER replied to ParraEels's discussion Cleary isn't an Origin player
"I agree 100% i would pick Katoa he young really good player 
There is no way i pick Moses and Clearly as i said its a young man game look at QLD they drop DEC and pick young Dearen  and won 2 
I think half the side sitting on thin fence
And i can…"
8 minutes ago
More…