Guymer is not an offensive threat whatsoever, and although he plays his heart out, he's left in vulnerable positions around the ruck if the tackle sticks. Fitness is an issue, due to not getting regular minutes across the last 2 seasons he still needs to develop his motor for running around for the full 80. I wish him the best but at present he needs a lot of work.
Last year I rated Samrani as a fringe first grader on the way up, this year he has cemented himself as a starting centre, he has a knack of finding the try line either for himself or a team mate.
Mataele has earned the right to be in the 17 every week, i don't understand why he is often overlooked, he has been impressive every game in first grade this year.
If Volkman is dropped for pezet i am going to blow up big time, Volkman is terrible in defence but no worse than pezet but he is way more creative in attack than pezet.
"Samrani has come of age this season and has gone from fringe first grader to earning a starting centre spot, i told my mate to take hom as a try scorer in his multi because he had a knack of finding the line and he delivered.
TDS is a more…"
"3. Volkman
2. Samrani
1. TDS
Last year I rated Samrani as a fringe first grader on the way up, this year he has cemented himself as a starting centre, he has a knack of finding the try line either for himself or a team mate.
Mataele has earned…"
Replies
3 - Ronald McDonald
2 - Samrani
1 - Mataele
3 Samrani
2 Volkman
1 TDS, Fox, Kelly
The Ibis (249m)
The Volkinator
Mataele.
Kelly played his best game for us so far.
3 - Volkmann - Hope he remains number 6 and Ryles doesn't put Pezet back there. Volkmann reads the game well and has an X factor about him.
2 - Samrani, TDS
1 - Fox
Good if Eels can beat Storm next week at Suncorp then the bye that's another 4 points and puts Storm further down the ladder
Still missing way too many tackles-particularly in the middle. TDS was great last night but missed 8 tackles and Guymer missed 9.
Jury still out on Guymer
Guymer is not an offensive threat whatsoever, and although he plays his heart out, he's left in vulnerable positions around the ruck if the tackle sticks.
Fitness is an issue, due to not getting regular minutes across the last 2 seasons he still needs to develop his motor for running around for the full 80.
I wish him the best but at present he needs a lot of work.
Guymer is a plodder. Terrible option.
3. Volkman
2. Samrani
1. TDS
Last year I rated Samrani as a fringe first grader on the way up, this year he has cemented himself as a starting centre, he has a knack of finding the try line either for himself or a team mate.
Mataele has earned the right to be in the 17 every week, i don't understand why he is often overlooked, he has been impressive every game in first grade this year.
If Volkman is dropped for pezet i am going to blow up big time, Volkman is terrible in defence but no worse than pezet but he is way more creative in attack than pezet.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 5 Next