Is png squad right now even good?

Alex Johnston-Riddled with injures and will only get worse in 2028 when his like 33-34.Not rlly that big of a signing imo.

Jarome luai-Gonna be like 31 years old or 32 and honestly pretty overrated if I'm being honest.Just not a good half in general anymore but who knows.

Joey Manu-Agaun gonna be 32 in 28 and his been out of rugby league for couple years.

Matty lees-Again gonna be 30 by 28.

Brian to o-A gun but has been noticeably getting worse and has been out of form.Again he ll be 30-31 in 28.

Zac Lomax-Honeslty nothing special let's be honest .

Connor Watson-Again gonna be approaching the back end of his career.

Dont really see the hype about this "avengers level squad"All of them are gonna be in there 30s and looking for a retirement check.So the only thing stopping em is health.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Has a 1-2 year novelty window then will fizzle out. 

  • There are about 20 additional signings left to go.

    10 to fill the first team.

    For the sake of the exercise, let's say you have to fill these positions:

    Fullback, Halfback, Prop x2, Edge Backrow x3, Bench Utility, Hooker, Centre/Winger.

    Who would you say they need to sign to counter act the speculation that they aren't going to be as good as people think. 

    Joey and Zac are on a combined 1.5, Jarome 1.2, Lees no idea what he'd be on, Too 600, AJ 300. 

    Let's say they've spent 4 million. They should have about 9 million left.

    • If they have 9mil left that's an average $400k per player. If they sign Cleary or Walker for $1.3 to $1.5mil that drops to $350k average for the remaining 21 players. They have spent a bomb and the fear for that team should be when they inevitably get injuries how they will field replacements because they will be players on minimum wage at that point.

      • An ok portion of their top 30 will be local players. They would be cheap too.

      • I'm challenging evryone to actually have a crack at filling their next 10 signings. It's easy to say they'll fail, it's harder to say who they'd need to sign to succeed

  • All those players will go stir crazy after being there for 1 month...plus imagine if wives/partners dont get along with other wives/partners...they are basically in lockdown for 10months...

    • It's a guarantee that an affair will be the first controversy 😂

      • Or someone's kids causing trouble.  Nothing worse than going to mates house and his kids are feral, hurting other kids and parents don't say shit.

        My wife refuses go to some mates houses because the feral kids.

  • 11 million angry locals surrounding your compound could be good motivation to bring your A game. 

     

     

     

     

     

     

  • Not to mention Matty Lees is currently sidelined from knee surgery. So how does he recover from that.

    Their next target apparently is All Blacks captain, Ardie Savea. He will be 35 once PNG are in the competition.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels eye Titans' Brian Kelly as Lomax replacement
"No player ever says " ya know what I'm signing with Parra as they have great negotiating skills " ,  amd not just due to us having the worst negotiation skills in the comp , if you have great negotiation skills , the person you're negotiating with…"
4 hours ago
Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Crystal Ball Time: 2026 Predictions for the Parramatta Eels
"BEM , boom .   Nailed it . "
5 hours ago
Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Archie's discussion Warriors injustice?
"I can't believe how much The Knights miss DylBoobs. Lol at the claims here that he " unlocks " Ponga 😂.  The silence is deafening compared to the start of the season when the usual suspects were crowing about how wrong we were as Dylan's turned the…"
5 hours ago
Wizard “Alcatraz “Sleeve replied to Archie's discussion Warriors injustice?
"And it's all irrelevant if they'd sent old mate for 10 as has been the ruling all season for direct contact with Pongas head down the other end.  Instead Knights lose their best player and Warriors almost push a grand stand finish .  
Warriors got…"
5 hours ago
More…