Oz: 8th best Covid-19 response; why?

A Lowy Institite study ranked countries according to how they have managed coronavirus risks. NZ ranks 1st, Australia 8th. The Bottom 5 were: USA, Iran, Columbia, Mexico, Brazil. 
Note with all the debates about whether democracies or authoritarian regimes manage public risk better, or whether left or right of the political spectrum guards public health better, one fact stands out in the Lowy 100 List. The more a countries' politics is shaped by populist nationalism and strongman leadership, the worse it has done, regardless of whether the strongman is left or right politically. 
All the bottom 5 fit that description: US under (the far right) Trump, Iran under (fundamentalist, conservative Islam) Khamenei, Columbia under (right wing) Duque, Mexico under (leftist) Obrador, Brazil under (far right) Bolsonaro. The key element of populist strongman regimes is that they don't tolerate any devolution of power, and thus they attack other institutions: experts like health professionals, the media, courts, civic groups, etc, and they deligitimate any opposition as enemies of the state and insult then mercilessly. 
In Australia: ScoMo allowed a devolution of authority to States, who then effectively ran themselves as small population countries with strong border controls and close relations between political leadership and relevant institutions (like health care and medical experts). 
The lesson is? Beware the autocrats who are also populists and nationalists. It's the worst combination. 

SMH article: https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/analysis-ranks-the-countries-that-handled-covid-19-best-20210127-p56x3g.html

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I think Australia is rather unique in that the states hold a lot of power (left over from colonial times), and anyway they are the ones running the health system. ScoMo probably could have held onto some of that power in the guise of national interests, but he did the right thing and handed over to the states what they do best.

    We saw various degrees on populism (QLD, WA), which ended up with a hardline approach, but luckliy as you say they are not autocrats (that notion is just about impossible here). Interestingly, I do believe our political systems would not have allowed Trump to persist as long as he did. Ultimately the pressure would have been great to do away with him long before the election. The trouble with Trump was that he just didn't listen to his advisers, and that was his downfall, and the downfall of the US with how they reacted to Covid.

    • Longfin, yes, the Aussie political system is better equipped to deal with would-be autocrats like Trump. Our political parties are stronger than the weak US parties (they can't control delegates at primaries), the party that gets the most popular votes wins power (power is formed in the lower house), and we have no power invested in an individual (no independent Presidency). 

      I suspect what we will see once elections in Oz roll around, is that Premiers are more vulnerable than the PM. ScoMo could rightfully take credit for strong borders and Jobkeeper, and Premiers were stuck with any fallout from lockdowns. Palaszczuk in QLD rode the popularity in QLD of no community transmission but Andrew's in VIC is probably in for a rough ride. But we only have to look to the US to see what would have happened if federal (non)leadership hobbled States. 

      • This reply was deleted.
        • I can only think that New Zealand has a woman as a leader and again the superior comes forth.

          There is also no doubt that Gladys has done a wonderful job for New South Wales......what a shame that the Qld premier is actually a man!

          • everyone bagged her at the time but she didnt let anyone in or out until the shit was gone, where we get too comfortable and reopen too soon

            • Jacinda was right. Her critics wrong. She won. They lost. End of story!

              • Imagine only having to manage a country smaller than Sydney ...  people who can compare her task to that of an actual country with hundreds of millions is either very bias or a fool . 

                • You do realize the virus has the same reproduction rate whether it is in a country of hundreds of millions or tens of millions or just millions?

                  The only thing truly small in your comment is your small-mindedness. 

                  • If you can't see how having a eeenie meeenie tiny little small population in a large space would make it substantially easier to manage then it's not worth even having the discussion .  

                    as I said before ,  by your logic our reponse to major earthquakes leaves hers for dead . 

                    • Wiz, are you aware the population density of NZ is 18 people per square kilometer? The pop density of VIC is 28/sqkm, of NSW 10/sqkm. Of course population density is uneven. Melbourne's is 450/sqkm. Auckland's is 300/sqkm. Apparently there is a small zone in inner city Melbourne at 8,000/km. There is probably an area in Auckland like this too. 

                      Your point, in other words, is completely undone by the unevenness of population density but the need to manage a virus with a stable Ro across populations. You have to plan for the most vulnerable. Except if you're the US, or Brazil, or India, or the UK, and you just roll the dice without thinking about you're social network weak points.

                      Honestly, I understand you're point about few people in big areas. But it is fallacious to overlook uneven population density and what that means. The virus, as we have seen in Oz, often enters through your airports and seaports, which are often in zones of high population densities. The story of containment starts there, not out in the boonies as your imagery suggests. 

                    • Hahaha classic Wiz right there.

This reply was deleted.

Latest comments

Nightmare Off-Season replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Great preview as always HOE, thankyou for this & for the massive effort again this year with all the previews and blogs you’ve written.
You are an unrivalled credit to this site and I’m sure 99.99% of the site appreciate it.
 
Always a little wary…"
17 minutes ago
Flow Basket replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"I thought the team was in great shape this season Blair could be a loss "
30 minutes ago
Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Crazy how his girlfriends brother ruined his career 😕 "
32 minutes ago
Flow Basket replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Disappointed joash isn't playing or Dean for whatever reason enjoyed watching there efforts, the team deserves a winning end after turning around the start"
37 minutes ago
Eelawarra replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Here's why Dylan Brown is playing today 
“I’d been thinking about Dylan for a while, and while we were never going to make room for him this last game, the opportunity came up,” Ryles said.

 
“Joash Papalii was booked in for surgery on his wrist,…"
1 hour ago
Cumberland Eel replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"The Eels should win but the last game they were favourites and should have won they lost. It really depends on what Eels team turns up but if they want to finish the year on a good note and gather momentum for next year then they really need to turn…"
1 hour ago
Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐 replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Hoping Dunster can somehow come back through the Ron Massy cup and at least be picked up by super league.  Im sure he has good footy left in him"
1 hour ago
parra supporter replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Yep matto and hands just on trial loan deals at present and still contracted for next season and Bailey was given permission to look however the team he was linked to (titans) now will have a new coach which potentially different targets."
1 hour ago
macybrown commented on CarloEEL2’s status
"Same wishes from me Carlo 💛💙 "
2 hours ago
Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Union 360 update,
"Don't care, bye."
2 hours ago
macybrown replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"Yes just hope they don't think it's in the bag before kick off. 
 "
2 hours ago
macybrown replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Union 360 update,
"What a horrible time for us to be wanting to buy any good experienced first graders. As if Perth wasn't bad enough. They'll all be interested in earning the huge bucks on offer and even use the threat of joining this 'whatever' for more salary.
this…"
2 hours ago
Hector replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"I expect the Knights to come out  and start with all guns blazing we had better be  ready for them  and go with them . It's every things crossed that we don't get ambushed. "
2 hours ago
Richard Jackson replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Thanks for the tip Joel.  Today the knights are coming...to our house...for a change.
They are motivated to not finish last.    We understand and although still without Ponga and and their injured 5/8, they'll be near full strenght and hoping..
But…"
3 hours ago
Cumberland Eel replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"Wouldn't surprise me if the Eels don't turn up but hope not"
3 hours ago
CarloEEL2 replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"Exactly 
he will love the lifestyle , can afford good real estate , the beach , will be hanging out at all the pubs doing his titty runs 
he will be having a ball !!!
better than sweating it out in the western suburbs if you can walk to the beach in…"
3 hours ago
More…

Grandson

Hey all,Apologies for any disruptions to the forum but just throwing out how happy I am ATM with a new grandson. First one. As you all know I have had some issues in the past and you have all helped me through. Just wanted to share this moment with…

Read more…
10 Replies · Reply by Joeyboyz Aug 25
Views: 241

NSW Origin Squad 2025

WESTPAC NSW BLUES SQUADAmpol State of Origin, Game OneSuncorp Stadium, Brisbane Wednesday 28 May1. Dylan Edwards (Penrith Panthers)2. Brian To’o (Penrith Panthers)3. Stephen Crichton (Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs)4. Latrell Mitchell (South Sydney…

Read more…
0 Replies
Views: 387

 

SURGERY FOR JOASH PAPALII

The decision to give Dylan Brown one last hurrah before joining Newcastle on a $14 million mega deal was “not a reward, but a mark of respect for the way he’s handled himself”, says Parramatta coach Jason Ryles. “I’d been thinking about Dylan for a…

Read more…
0 Replies
Views: 24

<script src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"></script>
<!-- Sidebar -->
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<script>// <![CDATA[
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
// ]]></script>