My ranking:
8. Hoppa to Dogs
7. Daylight.............
6. Lafai to Dragons
5. Copley to Roosters
4. Hiku to Penrith
3. Walker to Moanly
2. Jennings to Parra
1. Roberts to Broncos
1 & 2 are very close together and picked Roberts as best as is centre of the year and scored twice as many tries as Jennings.
Thoughts?
Replies
I guess this year will tell.
I'd have Hoppa 7 and Copley at 6.
I would put walker from 3 to 5 and move the others forward
Good question and the overall score needs to be balanced on the basis of what you gained against what you lost.
My assessment
We lost Hoppa for Jennings = +4
Panthers lost Idris for Hiku = +2
Bronco's lost Copley for Roberts = +2
Manly lost Hiku for Walker = even
Bulldogs lost Lafai for Hoppa = -1
Certain to be other opinions out there but I think we are a long way ahead of the other transactions.
Penrith, Parra and Broncos are the big winners.
Only time will tell who the biggest winners are. I think Bennet will weave his magic and Roberts will be the best centre in the game in 12-18 months
7. Hoppa to Dogs
6. Copley to Roosters - yet to establish himself
5. Walker to Moanly - what is it about square peg round hole. Gun centre shit 5/8 so where are Moanly playing him..... nuff said.
4. Hiku to Penrith - overpriced part time centre/FB/5/8 never established himself at Moanly.
3. Lafai to Dragons - kid can play, and back on left side will see his best.
2. Jennings to Parra - nsw and oz rep, close second
1. Roberts to Broncos - dally M Centre of year. Proved himself last year as an elite centre.
I think it is safe to say the Titans lost. Poor Titans.
-
1
-
2
-
3
of 3 Next