Fact - only three players have made their NRL debuts in the 4 years Brad Arthur has been head coach.* All three of his debutantes -Mau, Alvaro and French, were not brought to the club by Arthur, all we're recruited under Stuart or Kearney.I find this an unbelievable Stat coming from the biggest junior base on the planet, with Penrith.Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge Arthur fan, but with the plethora of talent coming through the ranks I'm hoping we can give a few boys a chance in 2018.Faingaa, Leleisiuao, Stone, Mahoney, Aukafolau, Tonise, Kaufusi and Brown all look like exceptional prospects.Ps, I think the only BA debutante he can lay claim to is Beretta Faraimo, anyone else ?In the past 4 years, there had been more Parramatta juniors debuting @ other clubs, than at Parramatta - Twal, Fuuimaino, Matterson, Davis ect

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I think he did debut in 2014, but was brought through the ranks whilst Ricky Stuart was coaching.

    Came to the club in 2011 - 12
  • Stone for me Chief; and Tep did debut in 2014. That is a while ago. He has done well.

  • Same, and no doubt Brad thinks the same, weve been a lot better since we stopped promoting overrated shit eels juniors, we are better off buying players in like brads doing, if the junior lads are good enough they will make it.

    This is the exact system i advocated for all my time on this site, our recruitment was the lowest and poorest in RL before BA got here and we had too many overrated juniors getting chances and we put off signing talent because there was always a junior we were relying on to come good which rarely happened.

    We dont need any more Mannahs.

  • Im fully backing BA on this one chief, we need players who are up to the task and fit in with our squad, if Brad would prefer to import players i think hes doing the right thing.

    If a junior is good enough he will make it.

    I think Stone will get a chance this year through injury and i rate him highly.

    Leleisiuao isnt an eels junior, he was bought in.

  • I understand where you're coming from Snake, but what I'm trying to convey is that the current mentality towards bringing players through the system is for them to have an extensive apprenticeship in Wentworthvile.

    I just want to see a few of the boys mentioned above given a chance to impress with some short stints off the bench if they are doing well in reserves.

    We'll see.
    • I understand your reasoning but to give a bench spot to a young bloke for the reasons youve mentioned is something you can easily do when you are a bottom of the ladder team like weve been for the best part of the last 30 years, youve got nothing to lose.

      But if we want to be a top 4 team like Brads creating theres not much room for that, you have better depth and quality in your team, positions open up less.

      I dont think we should have players like frank pritchard or Gower on the bench though, they are they type of guys that id be looking at to give a few young guys a go but we have no youngsters that have the body shape of frank, im certain thats why brads kept him, because we are so thin on big bodies.

  • The local junior argument has died. Look at Melbourne Storm.
  • I'm not only talking about local jnrs

    I'm talking about a player that has been brought in by the current coaching staff and making his nrl debut for the Eels.

    Only Bureta Faraimo from memory has done it.
  • I'm not only talking about local jnrs

    I'm talking about a player that has been brought in or through by the current coaching staff and making his nrl debut for the Eels.

    Only Bureta Faraimo from memory has done it.
  • Nothing to do with Kearney or Stuart. You can thank peter Nolan
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Bear replied to Eelawarra's discussion NRL LEGENDS EXPLAIN WHY THEY HATE BRETT KENNY
"My favourite player, along with Mr perpetual motion , iconic champions"
4 minutes ago
HKF replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Cooper Cronk: On the Parramatta Eels, Pezet, Lomax and Recruitment
"It's not about him being a lemon, if anything It's the opposite. 
To win a premiership you have to build for it, that includes building the roster, building experience in big matches like finals, building confidence, building cohesion etc, etc. How…"
25 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Eelawarra's discussion NRL LEGENDS EXPLAIN WHY THEY HATE BRETT KENNY
"When speaking of immortals, I can't fathom how Eels players can get overlooked.
Surely a real case could be made for Kenny, Sterling, Price, Cronin.
Its an abomination that not one of them have the honour."
33 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Blue Eel's discussion Real Reason Parramatta Coach cut Zac Lomax Loose
"You could be onto something Adam. It surprises me to no end that that was even possible."Lomax replaceable" "type of guy Ryles dosnt want". So much so that i'm thinking there has to be more in it, but it's only speculation on my part.
Perhaps it…"
40 minutes ago
More…