Who will be our next fallguy?

In the past, we have always had players who were our "fallguys", the player that fans used to like to bag the most and be used as a scapegoat for our losses.

 

Some memorable fallguys - Dykes, Finch and "The Great" Todd Lowrie (excluding his final 10 games for us)

 

Now that Tautai has also left, along with some other dead wood, it seems like there is no player in our roster who will be our "fall guy".

 

Can't speak on behalf of other fans, but there is not 1 player in our team this year that i don't like. Hopefully this is a good omen for us and we go 1 better and win the title

 

Your opinions are wlecome on this subject..

 

 

 

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Not that i have a problem with him but i am thinking robson if things arent going as well as we hoped
  • It'll be Cayless. You can imagine the comments already.
    He's too old. He should have retired last year. His back ended contract is costing us too much. Blah, blah, blah.
  • You can imagine how distressing not having an underdog is for me!!!! Last year my chosen player was Todd, the year before that it was Finchy. So far this year there is no underdog candidate!!

    In my opinion though, my chosen underdog for the year will be either Jeff Robson, Tim Mannah, Tom Humble or Shane Shackleton.
  • Tim Mannah? The bloke will be a rep player in a few years time, he was one of our best forwards last year and he will only get better with age.
    • You have just about made my point for me.

      1. He will be a rep player in a FEW YEARS TIME. Currently, his form, while great, is not good enough to earn him representative honours. Many players have the potential to be representative players, i.e. Tim Smith, but never get there.

      2. Saying a player is one of Parramatta's best forwards is not a huge call, as we all know that our forward pack has always been our weakness. Behind players like Hindy and Fui Fui there were few stand outs last year, especially considering the form of players like Brod Wright, Brendan Oake and Weller.

      Tim Mannah has enormous potential, but as a young forward he still has a long way to go. Young forwards take time to develop strength and often cop criticism as they go through this process. Further in a team full of players like Hayne, Hindmarsh and Little Morts, Tim Mannah appears to be a little bit of an underdog to me.

      Finally - sorry for such a long post - but I don't think this post is so much about a fall guy - underdog is the perfect way to describe it. Not everyone is a champion in our team, which means some players are slightly under appreciated - I think its the under appreciated that this thread is trying to highlight.
  • If most fans are bagging someone it is usually because he isn't playing well not because he is a 'fall guy'. We fans don't know most of the players on a personal basis so there is no reason to just dislike someone for the sake of it.

    Todd Lowrie was playing like a busted until he seemed to just throw caution to the wind and back himself - he played really well after that and everyone, myself included got right off his back because his improvement was a major reason for our late season surge.
  • Timmy Mannah needs to step it up another level this year. I would say he had a reasonable year in his 1st season. Remember, he made a crucial mistackle on our tryline that swung the GF melbournes way.

    He has one more season to impress before young guns Mitchell Allgood an Mitchell Johnston will be competing for 1st grade prop positions.

    I hope he kills it this year. He no doubtedly has a lot of potential
  • I take your points on Tim, I just think it is harsh for a young bench prop to be ever classed as a fall guy. If we aren't performing then there are plenty of guys in front of him that should be blamed first.

    The number 7 will always be deemed the fall guy at Parra until we win a comp, rightly or wrongly.
  • Ill just say with Lowrie. I still didnt think much of him during the finals run last year. He was just sooo bad that when he started playing good footy ( not great just good ) it seemed brilliant. Still glad he left. And wanted to punch him in the face in the GF.

    but yeh i think if players start underperforming this year it eill be easiest to jump on Captain. M.Keating.( who even took a bit last year when kingston was making that impact off the bench), Robbo might cop it a bit but hes a champ i hope not. Possibly Mateo or Inu. Just because we know how friggin awesome tanlented and skilled players they are. If they underperform and arent consistant they will start gettin the jeers.

    But i currently love this years rosters hopefully everything i said will be wrong and not happen
  • From the top 25 squad (and assuming these guys all get gametime due to injuries etc):
    * Jonathan Wright
    * Nathan Cayless
    * Jeff Robson
    * Brendan Oake
    * Etu Uaisele

    Some or all of these at some stage will be our fall guy is my bet.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

KingGutho replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels side for round 19 against the Panthers at CommBank
"That's a decent side, I'm glad big Sam is back, we definitely need him, also think Simonson needs to be at centre, and samarina in the 2nd row.
also Ethan Martin has signed with the north Sydney Bears.  Has been named on the wing this week.…"
1 minute ago
Poppa replied to Eels2025's discussion Jason Ryles... Report so far
"Now your talking Tad.....leg power is the new renewable.....I was talking to a 70 plus  mate of mine and saying how well we will look in our "cooly hats" pulling a rickshaw when the Chinese finish the Silk Rd  from Port Moresby to Brisbane. 
The…"
3 minutes ago
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels side for round 19 against the Panthers at CommBank
"And if Papali goig to be our 5/8 you think you play him instead of Brown so he can get better  for next year and players can get used to him being our 5/8"
5 minutes ago
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels side for round 19 against the Panthers at CommBank
"Got 1 cooler i am at night clubs
I work 3 nights a week Thursday Friday Saturday nights
From 4pm to to 5am"
10 minutes ago
More…