No chance . Zero diligence in his work . Not fit enough to have a big effort or repeat efforts , horrible decision making . Just a horrendous first grade footballer.
Anyone is better than Kelly. He is absolutely terrible. If he doesn't knock the ball on , or not play the ball properly, he gets 10 in the bin and costs us the game. He is shite.
Penisini has been injured too long and is not the player he used to be
He's slowly picking back up his form, was pretty decent in this game and kept Tallis Duncan out of it. Let's see what he looks like with sua on that edge next season
If he's going to make a career of it he needs to be as fit as he's ever been coming into next season and he needs to concentrate on the 1%ers . Get his defence right , get his attention to detail right and realise how he needs to win individual battles on both sides of the ball . He needs to win his defensive assisgnemt , he needs to win his kick chase and finish his work . He is a terribly sloppy footballler who doesn't have winning habits in his game.
I feel it's hard for players to come into NRL with them and the young guys have to work hard every week to build them but the fact he still doesn't have them at this stage of his career is a worry.
Eli Stephens > Snottie PimpinAugust 8, 2026 at 10:11pm
Agree, I think he has the talent and strength to do damage. But he needs to work on attention to detail and get all the little things right. I'm just not sure Kelly on his outside is the right option we probably need some genuine wingers who can finish plays. But next season is prob sink or swim for will
Replies
Better than Kelly
No chance . Zero diligence in his work . Not fit enough to have a big effort or repeat efforts , horrible decision making . Just a horrendous first grade footballer.
Anyone is better than Kelly. He is absolutely terrible. If he doesn't knock the ball on , or not play the ball properly, he gets 10 in the bin and costs us the game. He is shite.
Penisini has been injured too long and is not the player he used to be
Kelly has been one of us best this year
No way.. you count how many drop balls , knock ons and crap play the balls he has copped this season.
It's typical from a lot on 1eyed, you can have 10 good games, and 1 bad game and some will want the player dropped, then sacked, they're a weird mob.
Hot garbage. Couldn't spell 'defence'. Footy IQ of a spud. NSW cup standard is a stretch.
He's slowly picking back up his form, was pretty decent in this game and kept Tallis Duncan out of it. Let's see what he looks like with sua on that edge next season
If he's going to make a career of it he needs to be as fit as he's ever been coming into next season and he needs to concentrate on the 1%ers . Get his defence right , get his attention to detail right and realise how he needs to win individual battles on both sides of the ball . He needs to win his defensive assisgnemt , he needs to win his kick chase and finish his work . He is a terribly sloppy footballler who doesn't have winning habits in his game.
I feel it's hard for players to come into NRL with them and the young guys have to work hard every week to build them but the fact he still doesn't have them at this stage of his career is a worry.
Agree, I think he has the talent and strength to do damage. But he needs to work on attention to detail and get all the little things right. I'm just not sure Kelly on his outside is the right option we probably need some genuine wingers who can finish plays. But next season is prob sink or swim for will
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next