Surprised Perth or PNG didn't sign him. No NRL player should have to go to Super League with Perth and PNG needing to sign 30 players each. Even Perth could use a DCE for their inaugural year. I understand the $ conversion rate etc. but surely it won't be that much more than what Perth and especially 'tax free' PNG could offer.
I have nothing against the guy, he is genuinely quick but has a lot of errors in his game that do not balance with his abilities.
2 to 3 years ago I would have been pretty happy to have him, but he has struggled as defensively not being good enough for full back and just not instinctive enough as a winger.....good back up player or maybe that extra spot on the bench for the need at the time. Maybe the best example I can think of is say jumping to take a high ball and not getting a 50% result.
Yeah I'd still probably sign him with the expansion of the competition he's worth having in your top 30. Sometimes players just need a change of scenery like Brian Kelly or Lofi Khan. Sloan has a heap of defensive issues but his speed is elite
9 try's in 16 games and only 13 missed tackles , in a wooden spoon team. He's got terrible instincts as a winger 😂 I'd hate to hear your summary of Addo Carr who's managed 6 try's in 19 games with 19 missed tackles.
Sack Addo Carr Now !
Poppa > Wizard “Alcatraz “SleeveAugust 17, 2026 at 5:06pm
Good on you WIZ, do you want to compare their complete records.
"No player ever says " ya know what I'm signing with Parra as they have great negotiating skills " , amd not just due to us having the worst negotiation skills in the comp , if you have great negotiation skills , the person you're negotiating with…"
"I can't believe how much The Knights miss DylBoobs. Lol at the claims here that he " unlocks " Ponga 😂. The silence is deafening compared to the start of the season when the usual suspects were crowing about how wrong we were as Dylan's turned the…"
Replies
I think he has already signed with a team in the super league
Surprised Perth or PNG didn't sign him. No NRL player should have to go to Super League with Perth and PNG needing to sign 30 players each. Even Perth could use a DCE for their inaugural year. I understand the $ conversion rate etc. but surely it won't be that much more than what Perth and especially 'tax free' PNG could offer.
He's signed with Castleford.
Could definitely sign him for 28, he doesn't seem happy moving to England lol.
I have nothing against the guy, he is genuinely quick but has a lot of errors in his game that do not balance with his abilities.
2 to 3 years ago I would have been pretty happy to have him, but he has struggled as defensively not being good enough for full back and just not instinctive enough as a winger.....good back up player or maybe that extra spot on the bench for the need at the time. Maybe the best example I can think of is say jumping to take a high ball and not getting a 50% result.
Yeah I'd still probably sign him with the expansion of the competition he's worth having in your top 30. Sometimes players just need a change of scenery like Brian Kelly or Lofi Khan. Sloan has a heap of defensive issues but his speed is elite
Unless we have some juniors coming up in the outside backs who can make that jump ? Navna was pretty good wouldn't mind seeing him again
Just realised Marty said play on our left wing....I hope he is not thinking JAC has finished....he still has heaps with the right guys around him.
9 try's in 16 games and only 13 missed tackles , in a wooden spoon team. He's got terrible instincts as a winger 😂 I'd hate to hear your summary of Addo Carr who's managed 6 try's in 19 games with 19 missed tackles.
Sack Addo Carr Now !
Good on you WIZ, do you want to compare their complete records.
-
1
-
2
-
3
of 3 Next