Replies

  • Post 1980 - I didn't see our props before then

    Ron Hilditch
    Bob O'Reilly
    Geoff Bugden
    Nathan Cayless
    Fui Fui Moi Moi

    I've always like Paul Mares as well - on his day he could do anything

    For me Peter Wynne was a second rower
  • Geoff Bugden 1

    Cayless 2

    Moi 3

    Tookey 4

    Pay 5

  • 6.Ron Hilditch

  • Lol at earning a spot based on potential. In which case you could add anybody who has never played a game for us.
    • I think his circumstance was different. We saw a glimpse of his talent and the story of what happened is unfair in my book the docs shouldnt of even touched that tumour. I strongly believe he had the ability to be one of the greatest players of all time. 

    • In that case you can make another top 5 list of "players that in your opinion could have been great"
  • 1 - Timmy Mannah

    2 - Lee Mossop

    3 - Tanelia Lasalo

    4 - brendan Oake

    5 - Billy Rogers

    • lol

  • Nathan cayless was a legend
  • o'reilly
    cayless
    pay
    bugden
    Mares
    moi moi
    pay
    hilditch
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to EelsAgeMe's discussion Ryles/Moses comments on Pezet
"Yep Talking Parra had Tuilagi and Pezet at 9.5 and felt that was too high considering both had issues during the game, particularly the first 25 mins."
39 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Winning It Twice, Off The Canvas
"With To'o and his comment of "Hard work beats talent" leans into what i suspect with my comments below as well. Discipline, ie hard work to get back in the line and move up when fatigued , the cover defending the fullback getting back in…"
1 hour ago
Muttman replied to EelsAgeMe's discussion Ryles/Moses comments on Pezet
"Well said "
1 hour ago
Old School Eel replied to EelsAgeMe's discussion Ryles/Moses comments on Pezet
"They are spot on. He did more wrong than right. The bounce of the ball goes the other way on Smith try and his own, and his performance would be crucified. They were very lucky bounces on somewhat selfish 3rd tackle plays. He was also at fault for a…"
1 hour ago
More…