What are your thoughts on this top 15... I was surprised with a couple of selections and some of the ratings.
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"I know it's true LB, but I can't figure out why there's so much hatred for Parra. We're not relevant and haven't been for a very long time, I'm surprised we register any feeling at all, let alone hate.
I hate the Storm, probably due to their endless…"
I hate the Storm, probably due to their endless…"
"Does anyone have a stat that shows, say in the last 18 - 24 months how many rep games v club games Moses has played?"
"True that! I heard turbo was asked to join the blues this year in camp but declined stating he wanted to focus on the seagulls. Being injured recently not sure if it's true or not but be that as it may we need money bags Moses to focus on us. He…"
"It's a hard one ... if he had played rep footy more previously I would say yes
but your taking about someone who only really in the past 12-24 finally made rep teams and until this origin series had only been selected due to injuries to others
so…"
but your taking about someone who only really in the past 12-24 finally made rep teams and until this origin series had only been selected due to injuries to others
so…"
Replies
Yes I saw this ,was surprised Hayne got second as there are some well regarded names there,however completely agree with at least the one and two.Hayne and Slater had some great battles and have to say Hayne came out on top on a few occasions, but over their full careers Slater came out the best.That of course was made easier with Hayne throwing his career away and also Slater having only ever played for champion team's and with champion players his whole career.Had Hayne not have played for a woeful Parramatta team and a not much better NSW one, both through very lean years and against probably the best QLD team ever,He may have faired better
Hayne had the ability to be the best player to have ever played the game.
Hayne only had a good couple of years. The rest had solid careers, Matt Bowen should be higher. Hayne drop because on consistent form. If he grew up he should be number 1 or 2. Luke patten should be higher up.
Tim Brasher played in this era as well didn't he?
Sorry mate I think Jared played over 200 games for Parramatta and I saw everyone of them and I have to say that he was in the best three players on the field every time I saw him play. I vehemently disagree that he only had a couple of good years.
100% agree. Unfortunately, due to Hayne's incredible heights in 2009, he was constantly compared against himself in other seasons. Fans from other teams bagged him later because he wasn't running 90m to score. They failed to notice his deft kicks, passes, line break assists etc. As Joey says, he really was a complete player.
Yeah, RTS should be higher, at least top ten.
Matt Bowen was a fine player, but that's too high a rating for mine.
The title says century. Not past two decades. Try harder Brettles
I would swap number 1 and 2 for starters! Tedesco should be higher. Cant understand why Langlands isnt on the list. Strange list. What about Ken Thornett?
So he is saying from the year 2000 onwards? Thats not fair! Langlands and Thornett would give these blokes a run for their money
-
1
-
2
-
3
of 3 Next