Team first: Who put their money where their mouth was

Clint Gutherson and Dylan Brown. Two of the stars of the Eels over the Brad Arthur era.

Gutherson, a talented Manly junior who was recruited by Arthur and Brown, an Eels project developed from a teenager.

Plenty has been written about both players' contract decisions. 

Gutherson departed of his own accord when told he won't play fullback and a longer term deal wouldn't immediately be on the table.

Brown took a lifetime deal at Newcastle that was virtually impossible to turn down.

Yet for all the talk about Parramatta losing their heartbeat in Gutherson when he departed for the Dragons, it became somewhat clear that his talk about "I've always said I'll move if the coach thinks it's right" appeared to be something of a tall tale.

The above quote was said by Gutherson when asked about Parramatta's attempts to retain Blaize Talagi.

Gutherson was the full time Eels fullback from 2019 onwards, but had previously spent time at the back in 2017 and 2018.

When new head coach Jason Ryles sat Gutherson down and explained that Isaiah Iongi would be getting the number 1 in 2025 and that an extended deal wasn't on the table immediately, Gutherson looked for a way out.

Where was the player that had bled blue and gold for nearly a decade? 

A suggestion of him moving out of his preferred position, once actually made rather than asked as a hypothetical, saw the club captain decide he wanted to play fullback for another side.

Contrast that with Dylan Brown.

The talk about his contract value and length is no longer an issue. He's going.

But when Brown was asked to play hooker, he slotted into the 9.

When asked to play in the centres, there was no complaint.

And now, in his final match in the blue and gold, Jason Ryles has seen fit to let he and Moses have one last ride together in the halves.

It seems that when it came down to it, only Brown was truly prepared to shift positions for the betterment of the team rather than his own ego.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

        • Thanks HOE and spot on with your other comments 

      • Nice thoughts Bobby. 

        Another one you have over me, I haven't got any great grandchildren......yet!

        • Happy Days Dave im loosing count  I think its up to 7 . Wish they all would slow down.costing heaps in presants😂

      • He was waiving at your grandaughter , Broseph. Not the kids. 

        • Wiz you have certainly gotten out of the wrong side of the bed lately Bud

      • That is very cool Hector, all of it.

  • Gutherson brushed me up at Palm Clove , his other half is beautiful Blonde pocket rocket she smiled at me which wasn't suprisng..fark Gutho the clown and anyone disagreeing with me is a complete Wally.

    • Lol.  Mick knew from early in the peice that Gutherson was a brusher. At the moment mick, he is my most disliked player.  

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Joeyboyz replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Junior Paulo 2025 season,
"He's been putting on some big hits lately too. At the backend of games, when it counts and inspires the rest."
55 minutes ago
LB replied to Steel be with you's discussion 20 Years On From 2005
"You have a point. 2001 you had Canterbury and Brisbane too who were top tier teams. 05' we finished 1st we 8 losses. These days that amount of losses gets you 3-5 on the ladder. Tigers v Cowboys GF showed how week of a year 2005 was in the comp."
1 hour ago
Steel be with you replied to Johnny Suede's discussion Eels just lost claim to fastest NRL try ever
"At least we still have the biggest finals win ever since 1908, 58-0 against Brisbane. I don't see anyone beating that anytime soon."
1 hour ago
Steel be with you replied to Steel be with you's discussion 20 Years On From 2005
"Maybe 2016...we signed two huge names in Jennings and Foran. We also bought Gutherson from Manly which turned out to be a great buy in the long run. We also recruited Michael Gordon and Beau Scott who were seasoned first graders. Besides…"
1 hour ago
More…