Eels Blogs

Replies

• 

  Wizardssleeves official receipts August 16, 2018 at 4:28pm

  I know which player I’d have rather had over their careers . Billy’s a little grub , but from a footballer perspective and not just a YouTube highlights perspective his career has been much more successful . 
  • 

    Nitram > Wizardssleeves official receipts August 16, 2018 at 4:39pm

    x2
  • 

    Michael Ericson > Wizardssleeves official receipts August 16, 2018 at 4:53pm

    Highlights wise I think it’s neck and neck. Slaters has had more consistency but if you take out last year and the first half of this year Hayne hasn’t been inconsistent in my view. I think Slater though plays at the same level in nearly every game so he wins the consistency award. Hayne has played in some shocking eels teams though and I reckon if Slater had been in those teams over the years there is a high chance he would had less impact than Hayne because Hayne can create for himself where Slater, particularly early in his career, was more of a finisher.
  • 

    Offside > Wizardssleeves official receipts August 16, 2018 at 4:58pm

    Slater is a better all round footballer id rather him over hayne hurts to say that
  • Beaker > Wizardssleeves official receipts August 16, 2018 at 5:21pm

    Agree wiz anf affside. A real kent of a bloke and rule breaker but an overall damn good fullback.
    .
  • 

    the eggman > Wizardssleeves official receipts August 16, 2018 at 7:42pm

    Better team but not better player.
• 

  Cranky Brad is here!!! August 16, 2018 at 4:55pm

  Career wise, Slater takes it easy. Hayne wouldn't be close, not strong enough mentally to achieved Slater's standard. In saying that though when Haynes on, there probably isn't a player in the game I would rather watch.
  • 

    Michael Ericson > Cranky Brad is here!!! August 16, 2018 at 4:58pm

    I don’t disagree but it’s a lot easier to be consistent when your team is always in the top 4 teams in the comp.
• 

  George August 16, 2018 at 5:17pm

  I would say in terms of consistency - Slater in my view wins hands down.

  But in terms of skills and ability at their best - Hayne wins hands down.
  • 

    Frank The Tank > George August 16, 2018 at 7:50pm

    X100.

    There is no better player in the NRL than a fit, focussed and motivated Hayne - his only issue is that we have rarely seen all 3 of these attributes lately regarding Hayne. In my 43 years of life I have never seen a more complete talented player than Hayne on his day and probably never will. Just glad I got to see him in the blue and gold and at his best.