The referring was good except for that forward pass miss. This needs to be brought up or our opponents will be allowed to win with forward passes. This is the result of allowing BS to go uncontested from the first Manly game
The bunker checks for line drop outs so idk what happened there. If Gutho lost the ball it would of been a scrum as you said but if he didnt then Graham clearly lost the ball which is a 20m tap. So yea I dont know what the Bunker was doing.
Why did'nt Shaun Lane ask Guthomto challenge the knock-on call on him? It was too late when they saw the replay. As Brandy said, Lane should have informed Gutho that it was stripped if he felt so. Lane was shown on tele motioning the strip but did not pursue it. Go PARRA!
Just watched the John Morris press conference. He is filthy particularly the Fergo knock on where Brown made the half break off our line, oh and the scrum win against the feed.Morris always was a sore loser tho, even when he plsyed with us.
"Lurker, from memory and I was eating some grapes at the time, Ryles mentioned Simmonson also due to him being injured for last season (part thereof) hence depth."
"Chiefy, Coryn is entitled to his views, just as you and me are. No issues there. I’m not really trying to persuade or shut down a different view. I’m just setting the record straight for anyone else who might be following the discussion.
It's…"
"Hoe, there's no use trying to convince a person like Coryn. Might aswell argue with a stop sign
Never wrestle with a pig — you both get dirty and the pig likes it
"
Replies
surprised nothing was said it was forward out of the hands 3 metres
The referring was good except for that forward pass miss.
This needs to be brought up or our opponents will be allowed to win with forward passes. This is the result of allowing BS to go uncontested from the first Manly game
I thought there was a knockon when it happened. I was quite surprised when it was ruled a line drop out. They scored from the reset.
Longtime Eel definitely a knock on. I do not know how it was missed and why we didn’t challenge
I think Gutho knocked it on to first. Probably lucky we got a drop out, and not a sharkies feed scrum 10 out.
The bunker checks for line drop outs so idk what happened there. If Gutho lost the ball it would of been a scrum as you said but if he didnt then Graham clearly lost the ball which is a 20m tap. So yea I dont know what the Bunker was doing.
I can't criticise any of the line ball decisions out there today. The conditions were atrocious and the old Kogorah oval reminded me of the 70s !!
Why did'nt Shaun Lane ask Guthomto challenge the knock-on call on him? It was too late when they saw the replay. As Brandy said, Lane should have informed Gutho that it was stripped if he felt so. Lane was shown on tele motioning the strip but did not pursue it. Go PARRA!
Just watched the John Morris press conference. He is filthy particularly the Fergo knock on where Brown made the half break off our line, oh and the scrum win against the feed.Morris always was a sore loser tho, even when he plsyed with us.
John didn't win any friends with his performance. He is a young coach and is a passionate fella. He will learn.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next