With manly playing in pride jersey.
Will this lead to trans gender women playing in nrlw . Is there any rule in place for this happening . As this could lead to more issues in relation to this topic.
Such as the women from the swimming in America having to accept the trans gender man who raced to be included in women Olympic team.
Will this be an issue.
Replies
Trans genders should not be allowed to compete against other women in any sport...
The very real facts are quite simple and this is where it is all falling apart...
What you wish to identify as, doesn't and shouldn't matter to anyone to be completely honest... Just like the Manly players who are refusing to play with the gersey change this weekend, because of their beliefs, so should people, should they wish to, become a women from a man's body, be allowed to do so without rebuke... It's quite factually, their choice!
BUT!...
Thete are no amount of Sports enhancing performance drugs a female can take to be able to properly and safely compete against a man... And when allowing this to happen (trans genders in women's sports) you are opening everything up to major issues in possible injuries and one sided results, no matter which way you look at it!!...
Year after year we see gold medals taken from athletes, sporting identities being dragged thru the mud due to taking sports enhancing drugs... Yet, now the question is 'why can't we allow trans genders compete against women?'...
I was speaking to a very educated friend regarding this very topic the other day and we came up with a solution... All sports being all genders... No more men's and women's... All on the starting blocks together!!!...
Let's see then how many women and trans genders get past the heats?... Or into the top grade in sporting teams?...
Yes... I firmly believe you can do as you wish to your body... It's everyone's own right... If you wish to identify as a toaster even... So be it!...
But please... Before the whole thing becomes a bigger circus than it already is, keep some commonsense!!
100% Sean
Does a sex change include modifying the entire body (muscles, agility etc) to match a woman's body?
No? Then if any dude who brcomes a "woman" wants to compete against women, they are taking advantage of the whole equality thing and are nothing more than cheats and anything they achieve is laughable and fake.
And if I was a woman competing against him, I would organise a strike.
So trans women can't play in the NRLW? Am I correct? Are trans men allowed to play in the NRL?
I would think women who became men should be able to play NRL if they are good enough.
Provided their would-be teammates are comfortable with it.
Gutho seems to be going ok in the NRL
We always hear about the Pride Qld have in their jersey. Now their captain DCE and his club are front and centre of pride debate.
Is this all leading to DCE becoming the next Ian Roberts and face of LGBTQ NRL
I'd love to see more trannies playing in the NRLW comp. I'd actually watch it as the levels of talent would rise substantially and it'd simply be hugely entertaining to see petite little women getting pounded by some huge chick with a moe. The left eating each other over the rights of women vs the rights of trannies would be more entertaining than the NRL to be fair. .
Plus trans women ARE real women yeah ! Isn't that the general consensus they want us to follow or ELSE ?
How can they exclude trannies from womens sport on one hand but then tell us trans women are actually women on the other ?
And people wish to tell us how Manly players are hypocrites because they will wear a gambling logo but not a bum root jersey .
Just to add this in support of women's sport...
Women... rightly so... Fought for the right to play and compete against each other in any sport that men compete against each other in...
I find myself watching and enjoying these competitions all the time, whether it is footy, boxing, UFC, tennis or any sport they compete against each other in...
Why now take their right, to evenly compete with each other in sport away by allowing trans genders to compete against them!...
Isn't that then taking away the very rights they fought for in the beginning!?!...
Up until now, women gain their rightfully owned rights for this... Now the bodies in charge of all these sports and events will very un-rightfully take that away from them...
It's just not fair!
I have no problems with Trans people being treated as whatever gender they want in general society.
There are genetic differences related to peoples biological sex. These differences are mainly physical around strength so Trans women cannot compete equally in sports that are around strength and contact. It's unfortunate for Trans people, but life is not always perfect. For the sake of biological women we cannot have Trans women playing NRL.
Other non contact sports would be fine, Tennis and surfing for example.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next