Question mark in defense at the back against the broncos

With smith likely to again find himself at fullback, is there a question mark over his defense. He fumbled a number of grubbers against the tits, and against a much more punishing opposition in the broncos it could really hurt us. Again I raise the question, should Norman be defending in the fullback position, and attacking in the halves? I think it is unlikely to happen due to the fact that BA likes to show faith in players ability, which may be the reason we have performed so well this year. Again I ask the question because I just think that Smith may be a liability at the back and the broncos may exploit it...

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Smith just needs to only have eyes for the ball and not what is coming at him, aka put his body on the line and he will be fine.
  • I would say Smith hasn't trained much at fullback this year. His basic skill level for fullback would be down but hopefully a week training at 1 will help him a little. I don't know if Smith is the answer at 1 but Norman would struggle as well with the fitness required.
  • I have much bigger concerns with Kirisome's defence on the wing.

    Has no idea under the high ball , and its been a long time since ive seen a winger come flying in as often as he does. He carries the ball strongly but he's a defensive liability. 

    • Realise the jury's still out on Will's cleaning up at the back.

      But the confidence he would have earn't in attack last game may help him to be more sure in defence.

  • Will smith has played all his football at the back when he was with the knights you don't just forget he will just be rusty but he is quality
  • I'd like to see Hoffman come in at fullback and leave smith on the Bench.
  • pull a switch last minute will smith out hoffman in beau scott in for gower smith instead of frank the tank

  • I don't get why so many are infatuated with Hoffman...

    Many have had him replacing French, Gutho and now Smith at the back but I dont get why.

    If anyone watched his last game for Wenty, he was awful and that was on the wing. At Fullback he will be much worse.

    Even his games in NRL this year he hasn't performed up to his reputation. Defence is terrible and he rarely offers much in attack.

    Smith is the man 'til Bev returns or he gets injured.

    • First game back I believe, he was pretty bad.. I have always liked the Hof.
      Thought he was solid in the first 6-8 weeks without being flashy.
      If he can get back to his best, he will be a real asset for us
  • Smith is better than Hoffman who is a winger at best and bog average at best.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Hell On Eels posted a discussion
It doesn't change the better part of the last three years, but we won the 2026 Witzer Pre-season Challenge on the back of some encouraging trial form.
Gus Gould says trial results mean nothing. What matters is physicality, fitness and energy within…
1 hour ago
KingGutho replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Your best 19 vs Storm
"1: I Longi
2: B Simonson 
3: S Russell 
4: W Penisini
5: J Addo Carr
6: J Pezet
7: M Moses
8: Jr Paulo
9: R Smith
10: J Hopgood
11: J Williams
12: K Kautoga 
13: D Walker
 
14: TDS
15: J De Belin ( front row / lock )
16: S Tuivita ( front row )
17:…"
1 hour ago
Michael W. replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Your best 19 vs Storm
"You're comparing chalk and cheese, two totally different players."
5 hours ago
parra supporter replied to Acme's discussion Another Matterson Concussion
"Sort. Of- think the year for footballer start November so it be the remaining 3/4 I.e. if on. 600K 450 cap relief"
5 hours ago
More…