We all know that PK and Pricky Stuart are good mates, but to say that he didnt deserve those fines and to say that Jarryd hayne caled the ref "discracefull" and got away with it. I just think as a Host of an NRL talk show you cant be bias! look at sterlo, even though bleeds blue and gold, he is very honest and smashes parra if we under perform.

 

Don't get me wrong I like his point of view sometimes but his love for ricky is getting ridicolous! if he shared that a little bit to other teams it might be a more succseful show!

 

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Maybe they should fine journalists who say Ricky shouldn't be fined.

    • Only problem is that Kent would still walk away scott free as he does not in any way qualify as a journalist.

      Paul Kent is to journalism what Paul Kent is to first-grade rugby league.

  • I've always had this view on criticising referees given I used to be a ref. Constructive criticism should be allowed. I've had coaches come up to me after a match and tell me they didn't agree with some of my decisions and provided they didn't go overboard and they kept their cool I didn't have a problem. It's all part of letting coaches and players be heard. It builds a good relationship between them and the refs and also allows them to gain a better understanding of the rules.

    We want players and coaches to be themselves in the media and show their true feelings following a match and when they do they get crucified and then fined by the NRL. I'm all for allowing players and referees to put across their viewpoint on a refereeing performance provided it is done so constructively and doesn't personally attack referees or imply they are bias.

    • Excellent reply.
    • Referees, despite some enormous blunders, have to make a call in real time with no video assistance.

      Video referees, on the other hand, are complete morons.

    • Unfortunately NRL referees are admittedly biased.

      They acknowledge they review video / write "cheat sheets" for common offences by certain individuals (Ben Smith / hold down in tackle anyone?). 

      It's really bad form.

  • Mate you have been bias yourself.

     

    Kent did mention other names in the same sentence and not just Hayne.

     

    What he said about Stuart I agree with. Why should he be fined? He didnt question their integrity. All he said was they had a bad performance.

    • So the way that Ricky accted was totaly acceptable then?

       

      It was emnarssing last year and even raiders fans have had enough

    • Stuart should've been fined for impersonating an NRL coach.

    • You're right Super. Ricky does do a fine impersonation of a coach.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Phil Mann replied to EelsAgeMe's discussion Ryles/Moses comments on Pezet
"I was ready to cut his foot off with a couple of those kicks.  Luckilly the bounce went our way, but with a minute to go and having the Bronco's pinned on their line, the potential for given them any sort of field position with one set to play was…"
5 minutes ago
LB replied to Pato's discussion Xerri
"lol those in glass houses Dynasty. Not fair calling Michael, who is quite good with his responses, dumb. Considering I went into detail about one of your dumb comments and you had no reply so I gather you had nothing to counter. So let's not call…"
14 minutes ago
Sparky the Eel replied to Blue Gold Legend's discussion Radradra, Hayne or Sivo - Most NRL Tries
"forget that lets be honest what if the Hayne Plane never hadthe dream to play NFL & Sami never left the EELS
imagine the back 3 being SAmi & Sivo on the Wings & Hayne at FB - the 2022 Grandfinal would of been a very close game in the end maybe even…"
26 minutes ago
Sparky the Eel replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Why did fans want Ryles head after 1 game ?
"one didnt want his headbut do think he needs a head of football someone like a Gus Gould at the bulldogs &his time at the Panthers to bounce off when it comes to coaching & recruitment of players.
 
who i would go for if Parramatta board get their…"
31 minutes ago
More…