Our worse halfback: Sandow or Kelly or Thorman?

LMAO now go for it....IMO Chris Thorman was the worse I've laid eyes on. Dunno who followed on after him cos I ended up in the USA (where I'm going back early next year, plus I'm travelling thru Canada as well)...who's the worse in your opinion? This should be a laugh!

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Kelly

  • Kelly, then daylight

  • If u include the players attitude and effort into the decision then hands down Sandow.
  • A toss up between Dud Kelly & Stu Galbraith.

  • If you are talking about actual performance on the field then I fail to understand how you can possibly include Sandow.


    He got players player last year for shits sake!

  • 1.Jason Bell 1992 5 
    2. Stu Galbraith 1992-94 38 
    3. Tulsen Tollett 1993-94 12 
    4. Chris Lawler 1994-97 27 
    5. Keith Blackett 1994 1 
    6. John Frare 1994 3 
    7. Gary Freeman 1996 21 
    8. John Simon 1997-98 41 
    9. David Penna 1998-2000 38 
    10. Troy Pezet 1998 2 
    11. Ben Kusto 1999-2002 14 
    12. PJ Marsh 2000-01 14 
    13. Jason Taylor 2001 26 
    14. Andrew McFadden 2002 17 
    15. Adam Dykes 2002-04 11 
    16. Brad Drew 2002 6 
    17. James Webster 2003 1 
    18. Paul Green 2003 7 
    19. Michael Witt 2003-04 27 
    20. Chris Thorman 2004 4 
    21. Tim Smith 2005-08 71 
    22. Jeremy Smith 2006 10 

    23. Brett Finch 2008-09 2 
    24. Kris Keating 2009 1 
    25. Jeff Robson 2009
    • John Simon the Pieman was alright. Halfback in a team that, bar 10 minutes of rubbish, probably should have won the comp in 98.

      Jason Taylor was serviceable as was Robson, again like the Pieman, good enough that it was possible to win a comp with them if things fell our way.

      Tim Smith I thought was a good halfback and was another player not properly managed by the club.

      The rest on that list sucked balls.

    • Some greats of the game in that list
  • That was our halfbacks from sterling to sandow according to news.con
  • Worst I think are david penna and jeremy smith
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Eelawarra posted a discussion
7 minutes ago
LB replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels intrested in Cody ramsey
"I wouldn't say Tupou is as fast as he used to be, but was not overly fast to begin with. His skill is in carries and under the high ball"
10 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to LB's discussion Three Sydney clubs circle Radley
"Radley is only 27, last 4 seasons he has played - 19 games, 21 games, 23 games and 20 games this year. Has played a lot of second row at Easts this year as well.
I think it's a no brainer, quality player, without doubt. He dosnt miss as many games…"
19 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Roy tannous's discussion Eels intrested in Cody ramsey
"Yep, said he wanted another 5 years..... having depth can be a difficult thing, something that Parra is not used to for many a year......I think again the way that Ryles manager's it is key.
If you look at Roosters this year, they had a horrible…"
27 minutes ago
More…