Our Top 25 (edited)

I'm going to put my hand up. I'm confused about which players make up our top 25. As fans, we may be close to being able to add things up, but I would like to actually know. This would prevent much of the criticism about player selection at a time where the cap dictates who we can select on a weekly basis.
On another note, clubs like Parramatta are forced to fill many places in the top 25 with players who may not make the top 25 at other clubs. It is difficult to compete against clubs who have representative level players occupying 13 of the top 17 places (hello Roosters). Then again, the NRL's official salary cap document provides ready made excuses for how certain clubs can stay under the cap. How ridiculous is it when the official governing body has the reasons that you can sign certain players for less than people think in their own documents!
Who are our top 25?


EDIT (hope you don't mind Sixties) 

Suspected Top 25?

I also attempted to put them in some sort of order, from most cap $ to least - Miatch

Hopoate

Watmough

Sandow

Norman

Lussick

Peats

Mannah (long service dispensation means he's lower than you might expect)

Takairangi

Pauli

Morgan

Terepo

Radradra

Moeroa

Junior Paulo

Edwards

De Gois

Joe Paulo

Ma'u

Gower

Robinson

Champion

Matterson

Toutai

Folau?

Pritchard?

Notable not ins - Wicks? Fa'aso?, Kelly, Alvaro, Fairimo, Crooks?, Cody Nelson?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I'm pretty sure it's
    Robinson
    Radradra
    Takairangi
    Hopoate
    Morgan
    Champion
    Faraimo
    Folau
    Norman
    Sandow
    Kelly
    Peats
    De Gois
    Wicks
    Mannah
    Lussick
    Ju Paulo
    Jo Paulo
    Álvaro
    Ma'u
    Moeroa
    Watmough
    Gower
    Fa'oso
    Terepo
    • It can't be Kelly otherwise he would be playing this week. I'm pretty sure Alvaro got special dispensation to playso he is not top 25 either.  Faraimo was dropped due to 2nd tier issues so he isn't top 25 either. Which means there are a fewplayers in our top 25 (getting paid good coin) that are not first grade quality. That is our fault for signing them to big contracts.

      We can bitch and moan all we like but the rules are in place and we need to follow them. Also it is our stupid fault for having such shit players in our top 25

    • I think that you've included players not in the top 25 there. Eg Faraimo and Alvaro. I would also see Pauli in the top 25. This is the point. We are speculating.
    • No Wicks either according to the Daily Telecrap yesterday.

      I find this hard to believe though
    • I think Edwards, Matterson and Pauli should be in the Top 25 instead of Faraimo, Folau and Kelly but in saying this I also thought Fa'aoso was on a small contract also.
    • It had in the paper that Faraimo, kelly, alvaro arent in the top 25
    • Maybe we have players in our top 25 who are playing for other clubs?
  • Good team this week.
  • So Rusty is rumoured to give a few players $1m bonus for winning the GF - can anyone confirm or deny this?
    And it is not part of the cap
    But we pay a young players tuition fees and it is part of the cap?
    • Easy to cover up any payments with private ownership- they have no powers to check players private bank accounts, tax records, rustys private records and more importantly can't check companies with links to rusty.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Blue Eel replied to Eli Stephens's discussion 6 moreeee
"win lose or draw, i'm no longer a fan of the 6 again. They appear to not be fairly applied to both teams.
Lets look at the games so far. 
'Newcastle v Cowboys. Cowboys had quicker play the ball speed 3.3seconds average compared to Necastle 3.41…"
9 minutes ago
Mallee57 replied to Muttman's discussion Silver linings
"Two teams desperate to amend big round 1 defeats. The more desperate team will win"
33 minutes ago
Davos Seaworth replied to Davos Seaworth's discussion Stephen Kearney vibes from Gomer Ryles.
"2086"
39 minutes ago
The Badger replied to Desieels's discussion One game only, same old story. 40 years of this rubbish (spoiler alert REALLY REALLY LONG POST)
"Our NRL board is entirely made up of business people, insurance yaks and council workers with little or no football experience. That is a fact! 
To answer your other question, it's 2 words merged."
42 minutes ago
More…