Manu Mau or Proctor

I'm having an argument with a mate right now who reckons KevinProctor is a better player than Mau. He thinks he has better ball skills than Mau. What are your thoughts?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Kill or be killed! I know who i would want, Manu
  • Manu has a way better step,Fend and Offload and could put any player on there backside so Ma'u any day of the week.
  • This reply was deleted.
    • Mau!!
    • Good call Brissy. Both have their great points and I don't think there's much between them really.

      Ma'u with a more settled year in 17 having extended his contract could be a real breakout one for him.

      Proctor will be a quality signing for the Titans and wont miss Bird as a result.

  • Mau every day of the week!

  • Stats?
  • I think proctor is a good player. It like a lot of storm players the way Bellamy has structured his play means he looks better at ball playing because he has great players around him. That turnaround play they do where he passes to slater to shift out the back when they are on the line makes him look like a ball playing genius. However when you watch other teams they lack the timing. Manu is a true ball playing foward with a step and a good offload and is able to do it when there is no structured play meaning he can actually create something. Proctor is working off.a script. If I sat there and turned when I got to the defence when I used to play I can guarantee it would of ended with me copping sledges the rest of the game from the other team saying I was a soft rugby dog lol... how times change
  • Mau has the better offloading game
  • Would love to see how many breaks mau sets up, would be up there with the halves of the game with his sneaky offload
  • 1. Mau.
    2. Proctor from the Police Academy movies.
    3. Then kevin Procter.
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Coryn Hughes replied to Richard Jackson's discussion Recalling our favourite Fijiean Starschrist
"Tell you what there's some talent running round outside back wise in Super Rugby right now that I think would be great league converts Leroy Carter Caleb Tungitau Leicester Fa'iangunuku  Kyren Taumoefolau Jacob Ratumaitavuki-Kneepkens all these guys…"
25 seconds ago
Clintorian replied to Richard Jackson's discussion Recalling our favourite Fijiean Starschrist
"I still think Semi is the best winger I've ever seen. He was the perfect mix of speed, power, and footy instincts, some of the stuff he pulled off was insane."
4 hours ago
Darren Munro replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Another one
"100% not true"
5 hours ago
RustyNuts replied to Rabz S's discussion Official: Parramatta Eels upgrade Teancum Brown
"Where do you see Koina ending up if he makes it? Lock or 2nd row? What current player in the NRL would you compare him to?"
7 hours ago
More…