Replies

  • I know!! Has anyone given him a concussion test when he hasn't had a head knock? Maybe he's just a slow Kent lol
  • He's been a great clubman but I agree. How many hits can a bloke take to the head without having some kind of lasting damage?
  • Have to agree he's taken a lot of head shots this year. Its time he starts thinking about his own future.

  • I'm tending too agree after another failed HIA test.
  • The NRL must suspend him if he plays against the Tigers


    It's getting to the point where the game needs to protect Mannah from himself.
  • Mannah is not playing any where near where he was last year but he is still better than Alvaro
    Our props are our weak link
    Vave and Matagi are OK as bench props
    But we need two good starting props
    • He is playing injured mate.  Needled up and playing because he has to, due to the depth of injuries we have in our forwards.

  • I agree, I think the club could be criticised for failing in its duty of care to Tim if this trend continues. Anyone can see there is something not right with him, some of the contact he has been exposed to this year appears quite incidental (no penalty given) and yet he has failed another assessment.
  • Really?  So it is Tims fault that he has been smashed and received multiple HIA's.  Only way I will agree with you, is if it has revealed he has a medical issue that makes him prove to this type of injury.  I have a cousin who was a very established footballer, but has a medical issue that results in  him being knocked out regularly because of a weakness in his neck. Hard man, very resilient, but nothing can over come the genetic weakness.  On those grounds I agree.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Coryn Hughes replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Cooper Cronk: On the Parramatta Eels, Pezet, Lomax and Recruitment
"Can't match Russell Crowes TPA pull that's all this is I have no doubt cap regardless years in the contract I bet you there's a sweet TPA in case of emergencies I'd put money on that.The only way Parra are to land a guy like him is to go silly or…"
25 minutes ago
Troy Wade replied to Rabz S's discussion Parramatta Eels extend Josh Addo-Carr
"Great news - love the Fox's energy. "
34 minutes ago
Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐 replied to Rabz S's discussion Parramatta Eels extend Josh Addo-Carr
"Not officially 
Although he had another year left, it blocks the bears from signing him. I think one year is fine as it keeps him motivated "
41 minutes ago
EA replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Cooper Cronk: On the Parramatta Eels, Pezet, Lomax and Recruitment
"Difference is that Talagi played centre the full SG ball season that eels won the comp in 2023. He even played centre in JF that year. He didn't play in the halves at all that year. Risati has only played 6 for us"
49 minutes ago
More…