Manly weren’t robbed

The Dylan Walker try was a knock on the other angle show him Clearly losing the ball. If anyone says we were lucky show them that "try".

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

    • I also would have liked to see Oregon's try attempt again also!
  • True. But for the record I believe that pass went backwards from Turbo Tom. So final score is accurate.

    Cracking game, parra where the better team and deserved to win.

  • The Kafausi try being disallowed was also very questionable.

    • On one side it looked like her dropped the ball.  On the other it didn't.  I personally, agreed with the decision.

  • I believe was a forward pass good call. 

  • The pass was forward, Dylan walker dropped the ball over the line and they were gifted 2points for a high tackle which  wasn't high.

  • Worked a treat. I showed this to manly fan mate and he no longer thinks they were robbed. walker knocked on and bounced it.

    if we had lost we'd be on here saying the result should be overturned.

    i was surprised this wasnt mentioned on the footy show. but fittler was very quick to point out half the parra players stopped due to the whistle. impossible to say in 2020 with all the weird and wonderful try savers we now see that he would have 100% got it down anyway. 

    parra better team and won. even manly fans accept it now they see the replay of the walker try that the video ref decided to ignore.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Hell On Eels posted a discussion
This is the 7th annual Magic Round. The Caxton Carnival.
We’ve lost all but one.
Both teams are looking to climb out of the bottom four. Both rebounded with wins.
Down on troops, we were gritty enough to upset the then-high-flying Cowboys in a…
14 minutes ago
Parra-all-the-way replied to Angry Eel's discussion Herbie
"While I dont think we are any chance at getting him, id sure as he'll give it a crack!! Instantly improve our backline"
15 minutes ago
JC replied to Steel be with you's discussion The Parramatta Eels vs Melbourne Storm Rivalry
"We have the bye next week,  we play Newcastle the week after."
18 minutes ago
Offside replied to Angry Eel's discussion Herbie
"If he signed with us he'd immediately go backwards get complacent and injuries etc.. 
We could get him but it would require big money and Herbie excepting that he has signed away any chance of premiership in his career"
19 minutes ago
More…