This should be our team list vs Manly im hoping.  Williams and Guymer both did a great job against the Dogs,  and we cannot go with Kelma Tuilagi back in the starting 13.  We looked much better with Moretti starting and Williams out wider.  Both Williams and Guymer have a higher work rate than both Kelma and Kit kat and it showed against the Dogs

Saxon Pryke another great debutant and another with a high work rate may have cemented a bench spot for tge remainder of 2026.  In the centres Araz Nava made a fist of it and I would retain him in the centres with Penasini with Russell to come back onto the wing.

I would also keep Mataele in the 17, keeping out Kelma who imo drops out of the 19 completely.  Kelma on his day can be a devastating ball runner,  but he's too inconsistent and one or two good games means nothing in this competition 

Also Debelin starts. Walker much better off the bench.  Debelin adds size from the start.

 

1. Joash 

2. Fox

3. Nava

4. Penasini 

5. Russell 

6. Volkswagen 

7.mo

8. Jns

9. Smith 

10 Moretti 

11. Williams 

12. Guymer 

13 Debelin 

 

14. Williams 

15 Pryke 

16. Mataele 

17. Da Silva 

 

18. Teancum Brown 

19 Brian Kelly 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Did you mean 14. Walker?

  • Guymer killed it in the back row at the end of last year too. 

    • agree jack 

    • His defence has always been gritty but his offense didn't give us a lot of metres or line breaks. Bu,t he turned that around last week by hitting and spinning off every run and getting a quick play the ball like Cam Murray does. That gave us a few good attacking opportunities through the game. It will be even better against an average Sea Eagles pack.

  • is nanva allowed to play before kelly due to not being in the top 30?

  • Assuming 14 is Walker. Team list looks good.

    If Ryles can make sure Jr and JDB did what they did against Dogs, then that's a good line up. Just give them a simple job: run hard and direct, no bullshit offloads. Tackle with venom.

    Same goes for Dylan Walker. Cut out those low percentage hospital passes.

    I liked what I saw of Pryke. Add another 5kg of muscles and I think he would go alright. Maybe Williams should take him under his wings in the gym sessions.

    Nava deserves to keep his spot over Kelly.

  • I'd go

     

    1: J Papali

    2: S Russell 

    3:: W Penisini

    4: A Nanva

    5: J Addo Carr

    6: Lorenzo ( volkman missed 10 tackles last week 

    7: moses

    8: J De Belin

    9: R Smith

    10: Jr Paulo

    11: C Guymer

    12: J Williams

    13: S Pryke

     

    14: D Walker

    15: K Tuilagi

    16: T Brown ( debut him )

    17: TDS 

    18: T Mataele 

    19: B Kelly 

  • Is Sam Tuivaiti still out? I thought it was only concussion 

  • This is the type of coaching we need to support. This is the team that put a number on the Bulldogs through shear determination, grit, and effort... they deserve the opportunity to do it again. 

    • Hoping to see back-to-back performances from Volkman, Penisini, Joash, and Pryke
    • Is Ryley Smith is okay with his Sternum injury to start, or did Talyn earn a start after last week?
    • Nanva could be a chance of earning that Left Center position inside JAC, and keeping Russell on the wing before he departs for the Bears.

    We have a good win percentage against the Eagles when Tommy Turbo's out, let's keep that going and notch up another win against an Eagles team showing some form.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Clintorian replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin🐐 - Mark O'neill's 🪓's discussion No Kemla* - Team list day v manly
"His defence has always been gritty but his offense didn't give us a lot of metres or line breaks. Bu,t he turned that around last week by hitting and spinning off every run and getting a quick play the ball like Cam Murray does. That gave us a few…"
1 minute ago
Clintorian replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin🐐 - Mark O'neill's 🪓's discussion No Kemla* - Team list day v manly
"This is the type of coaching we need to support. This is the team that put a number on the Bulldogs through shear determination, grit, and effort... they deserve the opportunity to do it again. 

Hoping to see back-to-back performances from Volkman,…"
4 minutes ago
Billy Bob replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin🐐 - Mark O'neill's 🪓's discussion No Kemla* - Team list day v manly
"Is Sam Tuivaiti still out? I thought it was only concussion "
4 minutes ago
KingGutho replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin🐐 - Mark O'neill's 🪓's discussion No Kemla* - Team list day v manly
"I'd go
 
1: J Papali
2: S Russell 
3:: W Penisini
4: A Nanva
5: J Addo Carr
6: Lorenzo ( volkman missed 10 tackles last week 
7: moses
8: J De Belin
9: R Smith
10: Jr Paulo
11: C Guymer
12: J Williams
13: S Pryke
 
14: D Walker
15: K Tuilagi
16: T…"
12 minutes ago
More…