Kane Elgey vs Corey Norman

Now that Sandow is seemingly on the outer, and given that the Titans are rumoured to be interested in Norman to partner DCE in the halves next year (although now they seem hell bent on re-signing Elgey after his game on the weekend). My thoughts are neither Norman or Foran are halfbacks, so they shouldn't be partnered next season. I believe we need a traditional half to partner Foz next season. Likewise for the Titans, both DCE and Elgey are halfbacks so perhaps a straight swap might be an option for the Eels. Release Norman and sign Elgey. It's a win/win for both clubs.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I personally think Norman is a better half than Elgey is. I think Norman looks really dangerous going to the line with Manu running off him, he can put Manu through a good hole and it also seems as if his own running game has improved.. He's been making a fair few half breaks lately. Norman played a part in all 3 tries that we scored on the weekend, setting up 2 himself with nice cut out balls. I also dont find him a defensive liability besides his bad habit of shooting out and leaving his centre and winger 2 on 3 occasionally, but this problem can be coached out of him. I think once Semi is back Norman will look a lot more dangerous as well, playing with Manu, Taka and Radradra down the left side. Norman also has the ability to play Fullback which is good for depth, i don't believe Elgey can play any other positions? (Correct me if wrong).

  • If Norman is a better "half" than Elgey, this raises the question of the distinction between half back and five eight. Some say it has dissolved to the extent halves stick to one side. Norman repeatedly says he is a 5/8 here to play 5/8, so would he opt for a 7 on his back? And Sandow is our main kicker, so would Foran and Norman suffice for kicking duties (especially clearing kicks)?
  • Norman will be at the Eels if Sandow isn't. Simple as that.

  • Norman isn't going anywhere he will be playing in the halves next year with foz and sandow will be someone else's problem.
  • No way Keep Norman

  • With Norman and Foran I think we can almost go with a "traditional" halves pairing. Norman isn't that quick when he has to make a decision that's when you see him run a sweep play he takes it to the line but then stops and looks for his option whereas when you see Foran do the same play he runs much faster but knows where his options are so the defence has to make a rushed decision and that's where Foran shines. I think Norman can play first receiver  with Foran here. He still has that running element which can hold up a defence but also he doesn't have to worry about running a sweep play most of the time. There is still room for movement with this structure.

    The most important thing with whatever halves we go with is that they have options. We still seem to be lacking a bit in that area.

  • Ham, agreed on Norman. Note, to add to that observation, that Norman looks quite dangerous on the short side. With less room to move and less options, Norman runs at the line faster, passes later, picks the runner with space more often, along with breaking the line more often. It's like Norman can sometimes be a "short side Foran", shall we say?

    Which, if correct, would suggest a Foran/Norman halves combo could benefit from them swapping sides as per field position, Norman on short side and Foran on open side???
  • Doesn't matter which number is on their back as both do the same job. 1 runs the left and the other does the right, it will also be interesting which would be the dominate half as both are the same though Norman is probably is more gifted. 

  • You guys seriouse we need Sandow in the team he is the only spark in our line up with out his running and kicking game we will be stuffed
  • If Norman is better than Elgey then this Elgey kid must be pretty poor to be honest
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to Richard Jackson's discussion Flegg win against Storm
"Some players need to get sacked from a club and risk losing it all before they really knuckle down and put in the work.  Why did he get sacked, was it lack of discipline for footy and training or off field issues?"
1 hour ago
Parraboy replied to Richard Jackson's discussion Flegg win against Storm
"Nah I didn't watch the game I don't have too watch one game for my statement to be made I've seen enough in 2 years. His overrated"
2 hours ago
LB replied to EA's discussion Your Line up for next week?
"I love Twidle, you can just tell he is not a robotic NRL player, he plays with instincts. Not saying he is Munster, but Munster plays the same. Apa gets the ball, looks to see what is infront of him and says "Let's try this". That can be dangerous…"
3 hours ago
DYNASTY.LOADING replied to EA's discussion Your Line up for next week?
"Iongi
Samrani
Simonsson
Penisini
Russell
Pezet
Moses
Williams
Smith
Moretti
Kautoga
Guymer
Doorey
Walker
Paulo
Tuivaiti
Latu if Ryles thinks he is ready
Izack Tago if we get him
Twidle

 
I thought I posted this earlier including explanations but…"
3 hours ago
More…