The bloke cannot even get in the 17 for NSW cup yet he was considered a chance of starting in the back-row in round 1. This shows, along with Doorey and Murchie being dropped too, the failure of the club so far of developing these guys to be better than what they were prior. Doorey i feel is better than NSW cup and Murchie is not that bad and should be in the 17. Momoisea is where he belongs to be fair. But man Momoisea was signed on a two year deal and was our second signing for 2023 season, they wanted him early and snapped him up.
Cut bait hopefully for 2024.
Replies
Doorey is great. He is young. Great to have him back. He will be a valuable asset as the season rolls on.
Murchiei is good, great forward coverage. There are better forwards that would probably come in and jump him pretty quickly but I really like Murch.
Momoisea hasn't turned out but it was worth a shot.
As expected, Momoisea is bog average.
If you chase shit and you sign shit, you get shit.
Murchie has been a major disappointment. I was stoked we signed him but has offered very little.
Doorey has been great and is way to good to be in reserve grade. I would have him on the bench instead of Makatoa. Yes he is an edge forward but surely he would offer more in the middle than Makatoa does.
Overall our new signings have been mostly underwhelming.
Agreed with Doorey, can play middle and edge.
I don't get the thinking behind dropping Doorey.. played well, should have been rewarded.
Well I would like Doorey for another reason going into this game, he could be a back up if Russell and Dumpster have any heart flutters.
Dorey is going fantastic. He's been close to our best edge forward. No idea why he's in reserve grade
Agree the other recruits have been underwhelming besides Hodgson who is going ok but hopefully will start going better soon
It was mentioned that they wanted him to get fit enough to play full 80. I think he could be a great addition to the edge and have Cartwright on the bench as a middle rotation.
Still not sold on Hodgson.
Defensive liability and to slow at marker.
Doesn't poses a running game and his passing from dummy half is generally poor.
Bem i think hodgo is doing what he was signed for to get the young lad into a first grader he is absorbing all the heavy shit early which is making hands look good
We had to sign cheap shit with Brown and Moses needing massive bump ups. Not sure what people thought our recruitment was supposed to look like ? We had the Dolphins throwing money at anyone from other clubs worth having , and we had no idea what Moses and Brown were going to pillage from the bank.
Did we expect to be signing Origin players lol. We got the dregs. A couple are going ok and a couple are going less than expected and ones dogshit it seems with attitude problems to boot.
-
1
-
2
of 2 Next